Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"My Weather" by Jane Hirshfield is a concise yet profound poem that explores the complexities of human emotions and juxtaposes them with the seemingly inert nature of objects and landscapes. The poem opens with a list of human emotional states: "Wakeful, sleepy, hungry, anxious, / restless, stunned, relieved." This opening captures a range of human experiences that oscillate between consciousness and unconsciousness, comfort and discomfort, excitement and monotony.

The rhetorical questions that follow, "Does a tree also? / A mountain?" introduce a profound existential query. The reader is nudged to ponder whether these elemental aspects of nature also possess feelings or states of being akin to human experiences. Hirshfield's questions imply a comparison that elevates the emotional depth of the natural world or, conversely, reduces human emotion to mere natural phenomena-part of the universal continuum of existence.

The structure of the poem is straightforward and uncluttered. This minimalist approach reflects the elemental questions the poem raises. It strips away unnecessary embellishments, directing the reader's focus solely onto the fundamental queries of existence and experience.

The second stanza shifts to more tangible elements: "A cup holds / sugar, flour, three large rabbit-breaths of air." The specific objects listed-sugar, flour, and air-are mundane yet essential ingredients for life and sustenance. By stating that the cup holds "three large rabbit-breaths of air," Hirshfield adds a layer of whimsy while also hinting at the measure of life that even inanimate objects can contain. The cup becomes a metaphor for the vessel that is the human body or soul, holding a myriad of emotions, experiences, and even the breath of life itself.

The poem concludes with a poignant revelation: "I hold these." The speaker declares that she holds not just the emotional states listed at the outset, but also the elemental aspects of the cup's contents. This confession unites the animate and inanimate, suggesting that the essence of life-whether in humans, objects, or nature-is a composite of various elements, both tangible and intangible.

In "My Weather," Hirshfield opens a dialogue about the complexities of human experience while highlighting the fundamental simplicity of what it means to exist. With just a few lines, she captures the mutable emotional states we go through and posits that perhaps, in holding these states, we also hold the world-animate and inanimate-within us. The poem challenges us to recognize the inherent unity between ourselves and the world around us, urging a kind of emotional and existential inclusivity that is at once humbling and expansive.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...