Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Randall Jarrell's "The Sick Nought," the poet's voice embarks on a contemplative journey, reflecting on the plight of an individual soldier amid the unfathomable enormity of war. This contemplation is interwoven with themes of insignificance, loss, and the paradoxes that the human condition inevitably grapples with. Jarrell paints the scene with ordinary but poignant images-grey pajamas, a sick worried face, household chores-all set against the ominous background of an unnamed war.

From the onset, the poem brings the domestic and the martial into unsettling proximity. The soldier's "grey pajamas and sick worried face" are immediately juxtaposed against the imagery of his "wife and baby travelling to see" him. This stark contrast between the familial and the impersonal aspects of war generates an emotional tension. The soldier, once engrossed in mundane activities like "washing plates, or mopping," is suddenly thrust into the machinery of war, his individuality effaced by its relentless demands.

What strikes most in the poem is its candid questioning of the individual soldier's significance. "How can I care about you much, or pick you out / From all the others other people loved / And sent away to die for them?" the narrator asks, exposing the irony of individual sacrifice for communal aims. The soldier is reduced to a "ticket / Someone bought and lost on, a stray animal," his agency diminished, his identity engulfed by the collective narrative of wartime nationalism.

This reduction reaches a nadir as Jarrell declares, "You have lost even the right to be condemned." In losing his individuality, the soldier also loses his moral agency-his ability to be judged, to bear responsibility, to be anything other than an expendable commodity in the market of war. This line epitomizes the despair and dehumanization that war inflicts, not just through physical damage, but by eroding the core of individual identity.

As the poem moves towards its conclusion, Jarrell presents the soldier as "bewildered" among his "terrible companions, / Pain And Death and Empire." These abstract entities-emblems of war's universality-dwarf the individual, rendering his understanding and his actions almost inconsequential. This sense of inconsequentiality brings Jarrell to question, "What is demanded in the trade of States / But lives, but lives?" Lives become mere commodities, traded and lost in the business of peace and war.

"The Sick Nought" does not offer easy answers or resolutions. Instead, it hones in on the unfathomable complexities and moral ambiguities that accompany the phenomenon of war. It reminds us that every casualty, every "ticket lost," represents a world destroyed-each with its own web of human connections, dreams, and histories. Jarrell's poem is a sobering reflection on the mechanics of war and the cost of sacrificing individual lives on the altar of collective ambitions, leaving us to ponder the inexplicable paradoxes of human society.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...