Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

The poem "Crazy Horse Speaks: 4" by Sherman Alexie delves into the complexities of identity, freedom, and destiny within the context of Native American history and experience. This installment in Alexie's "Crazy Horse Speaks" series is a poignant look at confinement, not only physical but also metaphorical, and how that impacts the cultural and personal choices of the individuals involved.

The poem begins with a claustrophobic image of "Rooms without doors or windows / the eternal ribcage," evoking a sense of entrapment that resonates with historical realities such as forced relocations and reservations. This lack of exits signifies the inescapability of certain conditions and fate, hinting at the reservation system that would later confine Native Americans to circumscribed lives. The "eternal ribcage" implies a confinement that is deeply internal, as if coded in the DNA of Crazy Horse's existence.

The phrase "I sat across the fire / from Sitting Bull" introduces a shared experience between two iconic Native American figures. This kinship is further emphasized by the lines "shared smoke and eyes. / We both saw the same thing," which symbolize a mutual understanding and shared vision. This isn't just smoke from a fire but perhaps ceremonial smoke, adding a layer of cultural and spiritual significance to their shared moment.

Despite their unity, their future appears constrained: "our future tight and small / an 8X10 dream / called the reservation." The phrase "8X10 dream" paints a vivid image of limitation. It not only signifies the actual dimensions of a small space but also satirizes the American Dream by reducing it to a boxed-in area with fixed boundaries. The reservation here is both a physical and psychological space where dreams and freedoms are restricted.

The poem then shifts its focus to a broader historical context: "After the Civil War / the number of Indian warriors / in the West doubled / tripled the number of soldiers." This surge in numbers might suggest empowerment, but the poem immediately undercuts this: "but Indians never have shared / the exact skin / never the same home." Despite numerical strength, the absence of a unified front-both in terms of 'skin' (race or tribal identity) and 'home' (geographical origin or tribal territory)-hampers collective action.

"Crazy Horse Speaks: 4" ultimately serves as an emotional and intellectual meditation on confinement and the limits of collective agency. While the figures of Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull represent iconic resistance, they are also emblematic of the broader limitations and divisions that Native Americans faced and continue to face. In this sense, the poem is both a historical reflection and a contemporary critique, questioning how much has really changed and what the future holds for indigenous communities.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...