Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

The poem "Crazy Horse Speaks: 5" by Sherman Alexie examines themes of identity, perception, and racial trauma through the voice of Crazy Horse, a historic Native American figure. In this poem, Crazy Horse serves as both subject and object-recognized yet desiring anonymity, revered yet burdened by stereotype.

The opening line, "I am the mirror / practicing masks / and definitions," encapsulates the central dilemma of identity. Crazy Horse is a mirror reflecting not only his own self but also the various perceptions and interpretations imposed upon him. The "masks" and "definitions" allude to the shifting roles he's been forced to adopt, whether as a warrior, a leader, or an emblem of resistance. These are roles that define him externally but may not align with his own internal sense of self.

The lines "I have always wanted to be anonymous / instead of the crazy skin / who rode his horse backward / and laid down alone" showcase the gap between Crazy Horse's personal desires and the public perception of him. The "crazy skin" caricature simplifies his complexities into a single, exoticized narrative. The mention of riding "his horse backward" may refer to the unique tactics Crazy Horse was known for but also serves as a metaphor for the misunderstandings and distortions that have clouded his legacy.

The poem then shifts to a poignant expression of racial trauma: "It was never easy / to be frightened / by the sound of a color. / I can still hear white / it is the sound / of glass shattering." Here, 'color' isn't just visual; it's audial, palpable, and frightening. The "sound of white" is the "sound of glass shattering," an evocative metaphor that connects racial trauma to a visceral sensory experience. Glass is often associated with fragility and transparency but also with cutting and pain. When it shatters, it does so dramatically and irreversibly. This could be a metaphor for the impact of colonization, the fragmentation of Native communities, and the shattering of a way of life.

The poem's stylistic choice to keep the lines short and staccato-like creates a sense of urgency and tension. This form mirrors the fractured identity and history it seeks to convey, the brevity of each line underscoring the complex emotions and thoughts that can't be easily contained or explained.

"Crazy Horse Speaks: 5" is a nuanced meditation on identity and the painful history of racial and cultural marginalization. Through the character of Crazy Horse, Sherman Alexie crafts a poetic space to explore the intricate dynamics of self-perception and external labeling, humanizing a figure that history often simplifies or mystifies. The poem challenges us to confront not just the histories we've been taught but also the assumptions and prejudices that may shatter our understandings.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...