Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Certainty" by Roque Dalton is a poignant narrative poem that grapples with the theme of human cruelty and the complexity of moral judgment. Here, Dalton constructs a grim tableau of torture, revealing the depths to which human inhumanity can plunge. Set against this bleak backdrop, the prisoner's uncanny ability to identify his torturer's glass eye becomes a revelation, casting light on the paradoxes of human compassion and hatred.

Dalton's poem hinges on an ironic proposition: the prisoner is offered a chance to "save his skin" if he can correctly identify which of his tormentors has a glass eye. The proposition is both cruel and absurd, another layer of torment in what has already been a prolonged ordeal. Yet, when the prisoner correctly identifies the man, the reader is left to grapple with how he knew. The answer: "it was the only eye that looked at me without hatred," becomes a haunting revelation about human nature and perception.

The "American" glass eye is described as "perfect," representing the illusion of flawless objectivity and precision. Yet, it's this very "perfection" that stands in stark contrast to the searing, all-too-human hatred that fills the eyes of the other interrogators. The glass eye becomes a metaphor for an idealized, perhaps Westernized, vision of humanity - an ideal that remains emotionally detached and incapable of either love or hatred. In the realm of torture, where humanity is twisted and corrupted, the mechanical eye ironically becomes a symbol of purity and, to some extent, compassion.

The prisoner's observation is not just an astute reading of his torturers but also an indictment of the dehumanizing nature of systems that propagate cruelty. Those who carry out acts of torture lose something essential: their ability to look at another human being without hatred. The poem underscores that this loss is not just a tragedy for the victims but also for the perpetrators, who become ensnared in their viciousness, rendered less human.

Within this brief episode, Dalton encapsulates broader themes of power, dehumanization, and the intricacies of moral judgment. While the poem is rooted in a specific historical context - one that involves colonization, state violence, and systems of oppression - its message reverberates universally. It serves as a chilling reminder of the need for empathy and the perils that come when it is lost.

Dalton's "The Certainty" is an enduring meditation on the complexities of humanity. It reminds us that even in the darkest corners of human experience, the capacity for nuanced understanding exists. But it also cautions that our systems of power can obliterate this capacity, turning people into agents of unthinking cruelty. Thus, the poem stands not just as a narrative but as a warning, a plea for the recognition and preservation of the humanity in all of us.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...