Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Still" by Wis?awa Szymborska confronts the harrowing topic of the Holocaust, drawing us into a reality where names are not just identifiers but embodiments of entire lives, hopes, and agonies. The poem navigates the complexity of identity and suffering within the confines of sealed box cars, which become a metaphor for the inescapable doom that many faced during this period.

The opening stanza places the reader right into the plight, transporting "names across the land" in "sealed box cars." The unsettling ambiguity of these names' fates evokes a universal dread, and the narrator refuses to offer false comfort by declaring, "don't ask, I won't say, I don't know." This lack of definitive answers deepens the emotional weight and historical heft of the piece.

The subsequent stanzas breathe life into the names-Nathan, Isaac, Sarah, Aaron, David-by assigning them human actions and emotions: striking, singing, thirsting. In doing so, Szymborska counters the process of dehumanization by reminding us that behind each name was a living, feeling individual. The poem vividly captures their struggles within those confined spaces, how "the name Nathan strikes fist against wall," or how "the name Sarah calls out for water."

There's a sense of impending doom in the stanza concerning the name David. The weight of this name, heavy with historical and religious significance, is said to be "too heavy to bear in this land." It implies that names, as carriers of identity, can also be damning, marking one as an enemy or an 'other.' The advice to "Let your son have a Slavic name" exposes how this form of 'passing' could be a matter of life and death.

One of the most poignant lines of the poem is, "a big cloud gives a small rain, one tear," suggesting that the enormity of collective suffering is often met with insufficient acknowledgment or mourning ("a small rain-one tear, a dry season"). The futility of escape, the sinister laughter of "night," and the "clatter of wheels upon tracks" create an environment so oppressive it appears almost surreal.

The poem concludes with a refrain of the onomatopoeic "cor-rect," echoing the wheel's movement but also perhaps symbolizing the bureaucratic correctness with which this mass extermination was systematically carried out. The "crash of silence on silence" in the final line serves as a haunting closure, encapsulating not just the cessation of life but the indescribable void left in its wake.

Szymborska, with unflinching directness, addresses one of history's most nightmarish periods. In "Still," names become the living, breathing entities that counteract the dehumanization inherent in the Holocaust. By focusing on the human aspects of this atrocity, the poem forces the reader to confront the devastating reality of individual lives cut short, thereby challenging us not to look away.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...