Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

The poem "Stop, Shadow of My Elusive Good" by Juana Inesde la Cruz delves into the emotional labyrinth of unrequited love through a rich interplay of metaphor and classical allusion. Often regarded as one of the most learned women of her time, de la Cruz was a 17th-century Mexican nun whose extensive oeuvre touched on topics as diverse as love, feminism, and theology. In this particular poem, she presents a nuanced portrait of love as both a source of profound agony and a transcendent ideal.

In the opening lines, the poet addresses her love as a "shadow," an "image," a "beautiful illusion," and a "sweet fiction," indicating a painful awareness of the unattainable nature of her desire. This sets the emotional landscape: a realm of illusions where the speaker feels simultaneously entranced and tormented. Her love, while spiritually consuming, is tantalizingly out of reach, a "shadow of my elusive good." These words strike at the paradox of love: its ability to feel profoundly real while remaining intangible.

Further complicating this internal struggle is the metaphor of the magnet and steel. The speaker says, "Yes to the magnet of your attractive thanks serves my chest as obedient steel." In these lines, she deploys the scientific image to signify the irresistible and unyielding force of her love. While this magnetism draws her in, it also reinforces her feelings of helplessness and lack of agency. She is the "obedient steel," powerless against the magnet's pull.

However, the poem takes a sharper turn as she asks: "Why do you make me fall in love with you, flatterer? If you have to mock me then fugitive?" The diction here-'flatterer,' 'mock,' 'fugitive'-shifts the tone from the purely elegiac to the accusatory. It implies a betrayal; her love is not just elusive but also mocking in its elusiveness. This sense of betrayal becomes a lens through which the reader can view the larger emotional architecture of the poem: love as a form of tyranny. The speaker feels imprisoned not just by her feelings but also by the object of her affection.

The concluding lInesoffer a resignation that verges on defiance. The speaker recognizes that her lover's departure is not a release but rather an amplification of her confinement. She acknowledges that "it doesn't matter to tease arms and chest if my fantasy carves you a prison." Even in absence, her love remains a form of captivity, sculpted by her own imagination. The notion that her 'fantasy carves a prison' suggests that her torment is both self-inflicted and inescapable, etched into the very fabric of her being.

Juana Inesde la Cruz's "Stop, Shadow of My Elusive Good" provides an intricate exploration of love's complexities, combining intellectual rigor with emotional depth. The poem serves as an evocative testament to the human condition, reflecting the myriad ways love can be a sanctuary and a cell, a joy and a sorrow, a life and a death.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...