Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Storyville Diary" by Natasha Trethewey is an expansive and deeply evocative series of poetic vignettes that reveal the inner life and outer circumstances of a young woman named Ophelia living in early 20th-century America. The poetry collection offers insights into Ophelia's struggle with identity, belonging, and agency through crucial aspects of her life, marked by experiences such as 'Naming,' 'Father,' and her encounters with a man named Bellocq.

The opening vignette, "Naming," tackles the theme of identity, using the act of naming as a symbolic entrance into the world. Ophelia reflects on the power of names to shape identity, revealing how her name was a "chant over the washboard," a moniker intimately tied to her mother's labor and hopes. Her name becomes an artifact from her past life, an identity she must navigate and alter as she journeys into her uncertain future.

The vignette titled "Father" delves into Ophelia's complex relationship with her white father. He expects her to be a "delicate colored girl," showcasing how racial and social expectations shape her experiences and identity. The gifts he brings seem transactional-conditional love based on her ability to perform the role he envisions for her. His scrutiny becomes a microcosm of society's gaze, simultaneously shaping and limiting her identity.

The figure of Bellocq serves as another defining experience for Ophelia, but in a different way. Unlike her father, who enforces societal norms, Bellocq offers a semblance of freedom. He allows her to "arrange" herself as she pleases for his photographs. However, the poem subtly critiques even this seemingly benign act by noting that the final photograph will ultimately "bear the stamp of his name, not mine." This line is particularly resonant when considering Bellocq's real-life historical context. His photos of Storyville prostitutes have survived and are praised for their artistic merit, but the subjects themselves largely remain anonymous, their stories untold. Thus, Bellocq's character symbolizes both freedom and another form of marginalization: the erasure of Ophelia's agency in defining her own narrative.

In "Blue Book," the tension between self-representation and external definition reaches its peak. Here, Ophelia becomes "Violet," transformed once again by another's perspective. Her performance is molded by societal expectations-she must perform her "tableau vivant," becoming "an object of art," another instance of her agency being overridden by external forces.

Two portraits follow, aptly titled "Portrait #1" and "Portrait #2," emphasizing her ever-shifting identity. Here, Ophelia struggles with the duality of being seen and being oneself, as she poses in ways she believes are expected of her. However, by "Photography," she begins to find some agency, learning the art from Bellocq. The poem shows her gaining a sense of control over her own narrative, something underscored by her learning to "obscure a face" in "Disclosure."

"Spectrum" pulls the reader back to broader social settings. Ophelia walks among "the weary," whose eyes are "sunken," representing the city as a living, breathing entity teeming with life and decay. It reflects her internal state and serves as a metaphor for society's downtrodden, who carry their own sunken dreams and aspirations.

The collection ends with "(Self) Portrait," where Ophelia wants to "stop time, hold it captive." It's a longing to capture not just the moment but her sense of self, which has been so elusive throughout her life. Her final thoughts are of her mother, whose diminishing figure embodies the past Ophelia wishes to both escape and embrace, a poignant realization of the struggles she's faced and will continue to face.

In conclusion, "Storyville Diary" is a tapestry of experiences, memories, and aspirations that weave the complex identity of its central character, Ophelia. Trethewey's verses expose the often painful complexities of racial, gender, and class dynamics in early 20th-century America. The collection serves as a vivid portrayal of the struggle for self-definition in a world determined to define you.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...