Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Natasha Trethewey's "Three Photographs: 1. Daybook, April 1901" captures a poignant moment in time, featuring the complexities of race, objectification, and human agency as they unfold within the frame of a photograph. At its core, the poem serves as a meta-commentary on the nature of the photographic medium and the tension between the viewer and the viewed, unfolding within the broader scope of American racial history.

The poem is narrated from the perspective of a photographer, presumably E.J. Bellocq, who was known for his haunting portraits of life in early 20th-century New Orleans. Here, the poem leverages the historical weight of Bellocq's work, applying it to a new narrative. It opens with the line, "What luck to find them here!" establishing an immediate power dynamic. The subjects, "two Negro men," are found, suggesting they are components in the photographer's constructed narrative rather than agents in their own stories.

The subjects, said to be wearing "clothes like church," and "collecting flowers in a wood," conjure an image steeped in Sunday reverence and pastoral innocence. Yet this natural tableau is disrupted by the photographic act. The photographer watches them "strain against motion, hold still / for my shutter to open and close." The act of freezing time becomes an act of control, further emphasizing the power dynamics at play.

The phrase "Bouquets for sweethearts" assumes an innocent narrative, which the poem quickly dismantles: "A blessing though their faces / hold little emotion." The subjects have been captured but remain inscrutable, their emotional depth unfathomable or, perhaps, purposely overlooked. They become objects, easier to "pose," their "childlike curiosity" making them "good subjects" for the photographer's lens.

"How well this arbor framed / my shot an intimate setting," the photographer observes, appreciating the aesthetic quality of the image, but failing to acknowledge the humanity of the subjects. This myopia is further emphasized by the line "the boughs nestling us / Like brothers," a striking irony that lays bare the societal chasm between the photographer and his subjects, who could never truly be "like brothers" in the racially divided world they inhabit.

The poem concludes with a chilling note of historical context: "Instead of farther along / By that old cemetery / Too full with new graves / And no flowers." This ominous reference heightens the urgency and adds layers of meaning to the subjects' flower-collecting. It points to the mortality that looms over these men, juxtaposing their lives, so easily "found" and captured by the photographer, against a background of nameless graves.

"Three Photographs: 1. Daybook, April 1901" is a profound meditation on the ethics of representation, scrutinizing the power structures inherent in the act of capturing a moment. In focusing on these "two Negro men" through the eyes of a photographer-whose lens has historically been wielded as an instrument of objectification-the poem calls into question the very act of looking, and the imbalances of power that so often accompany it. It also subtly critiques the ease with which stories can be constructed, imposed upon subjects who, within the confines of a photograph, are granted no voice of their own.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...