Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

The quatrain "Herrick" by Thomas Bailey Aldrich is an homage to the 17th-century English lyric poet Robert Herrick while also reflecting on the unpredictable nature of literary fame and survival. Aldrich uses the metaphor of a journey at sea to comment on how great epics can be forgotten over time, while seemingly insignificant poetry endures. The comparison of Herrick's poems to "cockle-shells" serves both as a tribute and a broader commentary on literature.

Theme

Survival and Transience of Literature: The central theme of "Herrick" is the unpredictable nature of literary survival, reflected in the contrast between "mighty epics" and Herrick's delicate verses.

Unpredictable Survival: The lines "IT often chances that the staunchest boat / Goes down in seas whereon a leaf might float" set up the metaphor, where the "staunchest boat" symbolizes grand and ambitious works, and the leaf represents modest and unassuming creations. The image captures the unexpected nature of what endures and what does not.

Herrick's Enduring Poetry: By likening Herrick's poems to "cockle-shells," Aldrich praises their delicacy and charm. Despite being small and seemingly fragile, they have endured the test of time.

The Power of Simplicity: The comparison of "mighty epics" with "cockle-shells" emphasizes the idea that simplicity and genuineness can have lasting value, more so than grandiosity.

Structure

The ABAB rhyme scheme of the quatrain is effective in tying together the contrast between grand epics and modest verses. It helps create a rhythmic flow that mirrors the ebb and flow of the sea, reinforcing the metaphor.

Style

Metaphor and Tone: The metaphor of a sea journey and the poet's tone contribute to the overall impact of the quatrain.

Metaphor of the Sea: The sea symbolizes the unpredictable currents of literary taste and time. The images of boats, leaves, and cockle-shells create a vivid picture of the literary landscape, where survival is often unpredictable.

Tone: The tone of the poem is reflective and appreciative. Aldrich acknowledges the unexpected nature of literary survival without lamenting it. His choice of metaphor conveys a sense of acceptance of this unpredictability.

Conciseness: Aldrich's ability to capture complex ideas within the confines of a quatrain reflects his mastery of the form. He conveys a profound reflection on literary survival with economy and grace.

Conclusion

"Herrick" by Thomas Bailey Aldrich is a thought-provoking reflection on the unpredictable nature of literary fame and survival. Through the metaphor of a journey at sea, Aldrich illustrates how seemingly insignificant works can endure, while grand and ambitious creations may be lost to time. The poem serves as both an homage to Robert Herrick's enduring poetry and a broader commentary on the transient nature of literature. Its concise form and vivid imagery make it a powerful statement on the values of simplicity, genuineness, and the capricious currents of time. The wisdom encapsulated in this brief quatrain resonates with anyone who appreciates the enduring beauty of modest and sincere artistic expressions.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...