Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Massacre of the Macpherson" is an entertaining and whimsical poem by William Edmonstoune Aytoun, a Scottish lawyer and poet, known for his humorous and satirical writings. Written in the mid-19th century, this poem offers a burlesque portrayal of a feud between two Scottish clans - the Macphersons and the M'Tavish.

Provenance:

The poem belongs to the tradition of Scottish verse, particularly the genre of Border Ballads. These were narrative poems from the Scottish-English border that often dealt with feuds, raids and other historical incidents. The title suggests a tragic event, but Aytoun flips expectations with the comic tone and absurd events described in the poem.

Context:

The poem was written during the 19th century, a time of significant change in Scotland. The Industrial Revolution was reshaping the economy and society, and there was a conscious effort among writers and intellectuals to preserve Scottish culture and history. Aytoun's poem can be seen in this light - it uses humor and satire to reflect on Scotland's feudal past and make it accessible to a modern audience.

Theme Analysis:

The main theme of the poem is the absurdity of historical feuds and conflicts. Aytoun takes a traditional tale of a clan feud and turns it into a farce. Fhairshon, the protagonist, sets out to "murder and to rafish," but his plans are undone by the incompetence of his own men. The enemy, Mhic-Mac-Methusaleh, is portrayed as equally absurd, presenting a grotesque caricature of a clan chief. Through these ridiculous characters, Aytoun highlights the pointlessness and absurdity of such conflicts.

Poetic Devices:

Dialect: Aytoun uses phonetic spellings to imitate a Scottish accent ("coot" for "good," "tat" for "that"). This adds humor and authenticity to the poem..

Hyperbole: The poem employs exaggerated characters and events (like Fhairshon's son nearly spoiling the flood by drinking all the water) for comedic effect.

Irony: The poem's title suggests a tragic event, but the story is comical and absurd. This contrast is a form of situational irony.

In conclusion, "Massacre of the Macpherson" is a successful fusion of humor, satire, and historical storytelling. Aytoun uses the medium of the poem to reflect on Scotland's feudal past and to critique the senselessness of such clan feuds. The use of dialect, rhyme, hyperbole, and irony add layers to the narrative and make the poem a memorable piece of literature.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...