Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Paul Laurence Dunbar's thought-provoking poem "Retort," the poet presents a fascinating dialogue between two opposing facets of human consciousness: the head and the heart. Through this imaginative exchange, Dunbar explores the dichotomy between reason and emotion, delving into the complex interplay between logical analysis and impulsive desire that characterizes human decision-making.

The poem begins with the head chastising the heart, declaring it a "fool" for succumbing to the allure of superficial attractions like "a trick of a tress" or "a ribbon smart." The head represents the rational, logical aspect of the human psyche that seeks to evaluate situations based on practical considerations and long-term consequences. It adopts a stern and critical tone, condemning the heart for its perceived irrationality and susceptibility to superficial charms.

On the other hand, the heart responds with a counterargument, acknowledging the head's concerns while asserting its own perspective. The heart cites the beauty of Phyllis, described with vivid imagery, as it points out the appeal of her "fair face," "raven hair," and "rosy red" lips. By doing so, the heart emphasizes the emotional pull of physical attractiveness and the immediate gratification it offers. It addresses the head's judgment with a sense of defiance and boldness, indicating that it values emotional experiences and desires even if they contradict conventional wisdom.

Dunbar's use of personification in this poetic dialogue breathes life into abstract concepts, allowing readers to engage with the internal conflict on a relatable level. The head and heart become distinct characters with their own voices and viewpoints, turning the poem into a dramatic portrayal of an inner struggle that resonates universally.

The poet's skillful employment of concise language and rhyme scheme contributes to the poem's rhythmic flow, mirroring the back-and-forth nature of the argument between head and heart. The AABB rhyme scheme creates a musical quality that draws readers into the exchange, emphasizing the alternating perspectives and creating a sense of tension.

"Retort" prompts reflection on the age-old struggle between reason and emotion that every individual faces. By personifying these opposing forces, Dunbar not only presents a vivid depiction of internal conflict but also invites readers to consider the dynamic between these two aspects of human nature in their own lives. The poem does not provide a definitive resolution to the debate, leaving it open-ended and allowing readers to draw their own conclusions.

In conclusion, "Retort" by Paul Laurence Dunbar is a thought-provoking exploration of the ongoing dialogue between reason and emotion within the human psyche. Through the personification of the head and heart, Dunbar skillfully captures the complexity of internal conflicts and invites readers to ponder the delicate balance between practicality and desire. As the head and heart engage in a rhetorical duel, Dunbar unveils the intricate layers of decision-making, shedding light on the intricate tapestry of human consciousness.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...