Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Jean de La Fontaine's fable "The Cobbler and the Rich Man," the story serves as a striking meditation on the nature of contentment, wealth, and the unexpected burdens that financial prosperity can bring. The cobbler, who represents the simple joys of labor and modest living, is juxtaposed against his neighbor, a wealthy financier, emblematic of the restless unease that often accompanies affluence. The cobbler's melodic labor keeps him in a state of bliss, one so potent that even the wealthy man desires it. As the financier is disturbed by the cobbler's incessant singing, he attempts to buy the cobbler's happiness, offering him a hundred pounds to secure his own peace of mind.

The dichotomy between the two characters illuminates the tale's central theme: the relationship between wealth and happiness. The cobbler lives by the day, finding joy in his craft and "content with daily bread." His earnings may be humble, but they offer him a happiness "short of heaven." In contrast, the financier is deprived of the simple pleasures of song and sleep, despite his material wealth. His fortune does not grant him contentment but instead burdens him with perpetual unease.

When the cobbler accepts the financier's money, he discovers that this newfound wealth brings a loss of the very happiness he had previously enjoyed. His carefree singing is replaced by a vigilance born of fear and suspicion. It's a transformation that plays out internally, wreaking havoc on his emotional state and illustrating how financial gain isn't necessarily synonymous with increased well-being. His joy is literally bought away from him; he trades his ease and his songs for a monetary value that promises long-term comfort but delivers immediate unease.

The cobbler ultimately returns the money to the financier, begging for the return of his songs and sleep. The episode is laden with irony; the rich man's money, usually perceived as an instrument of freedom, becomes a chain for the cobbler. Moreover, the financier himself realizes that his wealth could not buy him the happiness that the cobbler found in his labor and modest living. He experiences firsthand the folly of equating financial prosperity with happiness or peace.

The fable critically evaluates the societal assumptions surrounding wealth and happiness, drawing attention to the flawed belief that material gain naturally leads to emotional or spiritual enrichment. In the story, money becomes an unsettling force that disrupts the cobbler's sense of well-being, suggesting that true contentment often lies in life's simpler, immaterial aspects.

By placing the cobbler and the financier side by side in a narrative framework, La Fontaine engages in a subtle but profound critique of materialistic values, advocating instead for a life of simplicity, joy, and labor. Thus, the fable becomes a timeless reflection on human desires, serving as both a cautionary tale and a recommendation to find happiness in the humble, everyday aspects of life.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...