Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Wis?awa Szymborska's "Vietnam" is a poignant poem that delves into the complexities of war and the psychological trauma inflicted upon innocent civilians. The poem's sparse dialogue exposes the utter collapse of meaning and context in the face of war's absurdity. Comprising a series of questions directed at a woman who seems to have been discovered in a burrow, presumably hiding from the conflicts tearing apart her homeland, the poem unfolds as an interrogation that only intensifies the woman's disorientation and vulnerability.

The woman's refrain of "I don't know" serves as both a shield and a mirror. It reflects back the absurdity of the questions, which lose their meaning in the context of the senseless violence that has rendered such categories as name, age, and home irrelevant. The phrase "I don't know" acts as a shield of ignorance or maybe even an instinctual self-defense mechanism against a situation that defies logic and humanity. Here, Szymborska manages to convey how war obliterates not just the physical landscape but also the mental frameworks and basic social contracts that underpin civilized life.

Her final response, "Yes," in answer to the question "Are those your children?" strikes the reader with its unexpected definitiveness. It stands in stark contrast to her previous answers and serves to underline what might be the only fact that holds any meaning for her in a world that has been turned upside down. This single affirmation is more than a statement of biological relationship; it's a reassertion of her humanity in the face of dehumanizing circumstances. For the reader, it is a harrowing reminder of the real human lives that are buried beneath the headlines and statistics that come to represent wars.

Another noteworthy aspect of the poem is its lack of specifics. While the title "Vietnam" locates the action, the dialogue could be set in almost any war, making the message of the poem universal. The woman, in her suffering and dislocation, could be any one of countless civilians who have found themselves swept up in conflicts they neither chose nor understand. Her answers, or lack thereof, can be seen as a tragic universal language, spoken by victims of war throughout history and across the world.

The questions asked of her-"Whose side are you on?" "This is war, you've got to choose"-also reflect how war forces individuals into roles and allegiances that are often arbitrary or coerced. The insistence on knowing her side, when she clearly is in a situation of duress and fear, points to the absurdity of war and the moral ambiguities it foists upon individuals. The woman's inability or refusal to answer most of the questions can also be read as a form of passive resistance, a refusal to participate in a narrative that has already taken so much from her.

In "Vietnam," Szymborska has crafted a haunting interrogation of war's impact on the individual psyche and the broader social fabric. The poem offers no answers, just as the woman provides none to her interrogators, leaving the reader to grapple with the troubling ambiguities and devastating realities that it lays bare.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...