Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"To the Consolations of Philosophy" by W.S. Merwin is a poem that grapples with the limitations of philosophy in confronting human suffering and grief. The poem serves as both a thank you note and a gentle rejection, addressed to the philosophical teachings that have long offered 'consolations' to human dilemmas. While acknowledging the perennial wisdom found in philosophy, Merwin emphasizes that such intellectual comfort often feels distant and impractical in the face of immediate, emotional pain.

The first stanza opens with a polite but firm "Thank you but / not just at the moment," immediately drawing the boundary between philosophical wisdom and the immediate need for consolation. Merwin acknowledges that philosophy has always been there, but likens its presence to that of something existing "in another time zone," separated by the insurmountable distance of real human experience.

When the speaker refers to "those beautiful instructions," he evokes the classical philosophical texts that aimed to guide readers through the moral and emotional complexities of life. Yet these "instructions" seem inadequate now; they "seemed distant then" and "seem distant now," in the face of the speaker's current emotions. The poem suggests that while philosophy may offer timeless wisdom, its ability to console or offer tangible relief in moments of intense grief is lacking.

Merwin then evokes the poignant image of philosophy's limits by referring to "when the noose started to tighten / and you could say no more." These lines suggest a scenario where even the most rigorous philosophical logic breaks down: in facing death or extreme suffering, "wisdom" becomes irrelevant, words lose their meaning, and philosophy itself becomes mute.

The speaker sympathizes with the philosophical writers, acknowledging that their words were also "partly for yourself / unjustly condemned after / a good life." Here, the philosophy is not merely an academic endeavor but a personal one, perhaps written in moments of profound struggle or near the end of life, when the philosopher realizes the gap between theory and reality.

The most telling lines of the poem might be "grief is selfish and in / the present when / the stars do not seem to move / I was not listening." Here, Merwin admits that in the depths of his suffering, philosophical wisdom feels not only distant but irrelevant. Grief is a selfish state, focused intensely on personal loss and pain; it has no space for the rational or the universal. In such moments, the stars-the constants used throughout history to symbolize natural laws and eternal truths-seem frozen, and philosophy's efforts to offer perspective fall on deaf ears.

The poem culminates in a complicated gratitude: "I know it is not / sensible to expect / fortune to grant her / gifts forever / I know." The speaker acknowledges the rational truths of philosophy but emphasizes that this rationality has its limits. When one is submerged in the immediacies of human experience-be it grief, joy, or love-the consolations of philosophy often seem distant, if not entirely irrelevant. And it is this emotional terrain, resistant to intellectual abstraction, that Merwin's poem brilliantly explores.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...