Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "To Monsieur de La Mothe Le Vayer, Upon the Death of His Son," Moliere crafts an elegy that delves into the complexities of human grief, pondering the tension between philosophical stoicism and natural emotion. The poem is addressed to La Mothe Le Vayer, a 17th-century French scholar, who has lost his son. Moliere acknowledges that no amount of wisdom or philosophical grounding can fully insulate one from the anguish of such a loss.

Moliere begins by validating Le Vayer's grief: "Let thy tears flow, Le VAYeR, let them flow." This simple but powerful invitation acknowledges that sorrow has its own legitimacy, regardless of one's intellectual stances. Moliere implies that grief, in such circumstances, is not only understandable but also irrepressible. He recognizes that Le Vayer's loss is permanent and irreplaceable, sufficient to cause "the most wise" to mourn.

The poet goes on to critique stoicism, the philosophical approach that advocates for emotional restraint. He suggests that philosophical "precepts" are ineffectual in suppressing "the drops of pity that are Pity's dues." Moliere aligns himself with Nature, characterizing an absence of emotional response as "heartless" and hence unnatural. This is a poignant point, reminding the reader that intellectual ideals can sometimes be at odds with our innate human experience.

Moliere also acknowledges the futility of grief: "No grief, alas! can now bring back again / The son too dear, by Death untimely ta'en." He doesn't offer comfort in the form of false hope but emphasizes the irrevocable nature of death. However, Moliere argues that the worthiness of the departed soul justifies the depth of the grief. Describing the son as possessing "Large heart, keen wit, a lofty soul and rare," Moliere suggests that such extraordinary virtues make the loss even more devastating and thus deserving of "immitigable [or, eternity of] tears."

The poem serves not just as a compassionate message to a grieving father but also as a critical examination of the limitations of philosophy when confronted with profound emotional experiences. It argues that no amount of intellectual or moral grounding can entirely shield us from the visceral realities of life and death. In acknowledging the inevitable failure of stoicism to cope with such a loss, Moliere underscores the significance of acknowledging and respecting our natural human emotions.

"Upon the Death of His Son" captures the irrevocable nature of loss and the enduring, timeless aspects of human grief. Its empathetic and intellectual depth makes it not merely a personal address but also a universal contemplation on the complexities of human emotions when faced with the harsh realities of existence.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...