Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "A Ballade of Ballade-Mongers; After the Manner of Villon of Paris," Augustus M. Moore delivers a playful and ironic take on the ballade form, popularized by Francois Villon. The poem offers a whimsical series of unanswered questions, ranging from existential queries to trivial pursuits. echoing Villon's famous ballades that questioned the fate of characters from yesteryears, Moore adopts a tone of irreverence combined with a dash of existential wonder. The recurring question-"And who was the Man in the Iron Mask?"-serves as the poem's rhetorical anchor, hinting at the unresolved enigmas that hover over history and human life. George Augustus Moore (1852 - 1933) was an Irish novelist, short story writer, poet, art critic, memoirist and dramatist.

The poem opens with an acknowledgment that "in Ballades things always contrive to get lost," setting the stage for a litany of things lost or forgotten. By juxtaposing "last year's roses" with "last year's frost," Moore emphasizes the transient nature of both beauty and hardship. His questions about the "gentleman" and the "player" subtly probe the shifting standards of social roles and identities, capturing the capriciousness of cultural values and definitions.

each stanza brings a new set of questions that range from personal to historical to philosophical. The second stanza's question about the "ring I tossed" and "my mistress false and fair" situates the poem within the tradition of romantic lament, yet its tone remains distinctly ironic. When the poet asks, "But who is to be the next Lord Mayor?" he abruptly shifts from personal loss to societal concerns, illustrating the fickle nature of public interest and memory.

The third stanza continues to combine disparate queries, moving from moral and religious imagery like the "knee I crossed" and the "rod and the child," to questions about the price of herring and the nature of the Golden Stair-either a biblical reference or an allusion to mythology. Moore uses these questions to satirize the breadth of human curiosity and to mock our penchant for pondering inconsequential matters along with the profound ones.

Throughout the poem, the question "And who was the Man in the Iron Mask?" is repeated, reminding us of the persistent mysteries that haunt human consciousness. Historically, the Man in the Iron Mask is a figure of much speculation and debate, and by employing this enigmatic character as a recurrent motif, Moore imbues the poem with a sense of cosmic uncertainty.

The envoy of the poem wittily addresses the poets, acknowledging that "Ballade-making is no great task" and confessing indifference toward remembering "who was the man in the Iron Mask." Here, Moore deflates the pomposity often associated with poetic endeavors, ironically suggesting that while poets may grapple with life's great questions, their efforts, like the questions themselves, often dissolve into irrelevance.

All in all, Moore's poem serves as both homage and parody, honoring the ballade tradition established by Francois Villon while using the form to explore the transient and often absurd nature of human concerns. It's a fitting tribute that encapsulates the complexity and the enduring appeal of the ballade, a poetic form that has, perhaps ironically, refused to get lost in the mists of time.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...