Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"But Who Shall See" is a poem by Thomas Moore, a renowned 19th-century Irish poet.

Thomas Moore, born in 1779, was a prominent figure in the Romantic literary movement. He is best known for his lyrical poetry, which often displayed themes of love, loss, and national identity. "But Who Shall See" was originally published in Moore's collection of poems called "Lalla Rookh" in 1817.

Theme Analysis:

"But Who Shall See" explores the fragility and ephemeral nature of beauty, love, and happiness. The poem delves into the transient nature of these experiences and reflects on the limitations of human perception in fully grasping their essence. Moore contemplates the fleeting nature of life's pleasures and how they can vanish or remain hidden from our sight.

Poetic Devices: Moore's skillful use of poetic devices enhances the impact of the poem. Here are a few examples:

Imagery:

The poem employs vivid imagery to evoke vivid mental images, adding depth and emotion to the themes discussed. Lines such as "like small waveless lakes that lie... reflecting in their tranquil breast / Heaven, and the clouds that wander by" create visual scenes that symbolize the fleeting beauty of life.

Alliteration:

Moore frequently employs alliteration, the repetition of consonant sounds, to enhance the musicality of the poem. For example, in the line "The rose... the summer's loved and last," the repetition of the "s" sound creates a soothing and rhythmic effect.

Metaphor:

The poem employs metaphors to convey its underlying message. For instance, the phrase "Like shadows in the moonlight thrown" compares the fleeting nature of beauty to shadows that disappear as soon as the moonlight fades, emphasizing their transitory essence.

Overall, "But Who Shall See" is a profound meditation on the impermanence of beauty and the limitations of human perception. Through his masterful use of poetic devices, Moore invites us to contemplate the fleeting nature of life's pleasures and the inherent difficulty in truly experiencing and appreciating them. It is a beautiful poem, expressing hope for a glorious future when God's presence will be unveiled and the nations will be united in peace. It speaks of a time when pain and sorrow will be no more, and when the people of Judah will be freed from oppression, experiencing a restoration of their splendor. The imagery of a Fount of Life and the return of long-lost exiles evokes a sense of renewal and joy. It's a powerful vision of a future filled with hope and restoration.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...