Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"I Fight Against You" by Anna Elisabeth Mathieu de Noailles presents an emotionally fraught landscape where love and resistance continually clash, delivering a nuanced portrayal of emotional struggle and desire. The poet articulates a deeply felt inner conflict that is rooted in love but complicated by the impossibility of either its realization or renunciation.

The poem initiates with an immediate declaration of war, a fight against the beloved. This establishes a dynamic tension that pervades the rest of the poem. The poet strives to evade love's grip during waking hours, seeking to "wander out of [herself]" and ignore love's "quintessential balm." Here, the love is not soothing but intrusive, a "honey-scroll" that the poet would prefer to keep unopened. The paradox is that the love is both desired and destructive, a dangerous ambrosia that would disturb the equilibrium of her life.

As day surrenders to night, so does the poet's resolve crumble. She acknowledges that her "power against you is all gone" at night, admitting that her defensiveness is rendered ineffectual in sleep. It's here that the poem employs its most striking imagery, likening the invasion of love to how "Ulysses with bare feet stole up the strand." This analogy creates a narrative depth, suggesting a timeless struggle. Ulysses, a hero known for his cleverness, still had to struggle with gods and fate, just as the speaker must grapple with the overwhelming emotion that renders her powerless.

Throughout the poem, the dynamic interplay between internal and external worlds highlights a more complex layer of emotional turmoil. This interaction is brought into sharp focus in lines like "Through my glance, my mouth, my very breath, you gain/Entrance: by all without and all within." The beloved is both external, manifesting in sensory perceptions, and internal, lurking in memories and emotions.

The poem reaches its peak in its final stanzas. Here, the speaker and the beloved exist in a world where "nothing human reaches the lands of our ken." It's a realm removed from reality, where the poet clings to her beloved's knees, yearning for both death and eternal love. It's a paradoxical moment that conveys the depth of the speaker's emotional paradox-she desires an end to her struggle but cannot let go of her love.

And thus, with the arrival of dawn, the speaker "ceases to be," suggesting that her love, though resisted and conflicted, ultimately defines her. It's a dramatic resolution to the poem's emotional tension, leaving the reader to grapple with the existential question it poses-how much of ourselves is defined by the things, or people, we cannot let go of, even when letting go might save us? Noailles leaves this question delicately unanswered, and in doing so, gifts the reader a vivid emotional landscape to traverse, explore, and critically evaluate.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...