Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Arthur Rimbaud's "The Poor Man Thinks" grapples with the tension between materiality and the sense of futility in life's pursuits. The poem opens with a portrait of resignation as the speaker envisions an evening of solace, perhaps in "some old town," where he can "drink [his] troubles down." There's an immediate contrast here between the timeless, static "old town" and the speaker's troubles, which are presumably contemporary and fluid. This suggests a yearning for escape, a desire to disappear into a backdrop where modern concerns fade into insignificance.

As the poem continues, the speaker presents hypothetical scenarios should his fortunes change. The very notion of contemplating whether to "go breast the North" or "dwell in the vine-clad earth" with "gold to spend" embodies a kind of fantastical daydreaming. It's as if imagining these better circumstances provides a temporary relief from his present reality. Yet, he concludes these thoughts with a rhetorical question: "Ah, what is thinking worth?" This abrupt transition from hopeful planning to existential questioning strikes at the heart of the poem's theme-life's inherent uncertainty and unpredictability.

In the final stanza, the speaker dismisses his own thoughts as "an idle sin," a kind of indulgence that serves no real purpose. This nihilistic assertion rings especially poignant given that, despite his imaginings, he admits the "green inn" would "never" unlock its door for him. The "green inn" here can be understood as a metaphor for opportunity or fortune. No matter what he aspires to, the speaker suggests that some doors will remain closed for him. This could be due to societal circumstances, personal choices, or mere luck; Rimbaud leaves it ambiguously open-ended.

The phrase "idle sin" adds a moral layer to the conversation. The act of "thinking" becomes not just futile but somewhat culpable, as if contemplating a different life is a form of transgression. This brings to light the paradox between human agency and life's vicissitudes. On the one hand, thinking, planning, and aspiring seem to be essential human activities; on the other hand, these same activities can be rendered meaningless by circumstances beyond one's control.

In a few concise lines, Rimbaud encapsulates a universal feeling of existential limbo. The brevity of the poem reflects the speaker's dismissal of the very act of contemplation, even as the poem itself is an artifact of that contemplation. It's a profound, layered text that invites the reader to question the very act of questioning, to ponder the worth of pondering. The poem serves as a reminder of the complex interplay between our internal worlds and the external circumstances that frame them, a delicate balance that makes life as confounding as it is fascinating.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...