Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Diomedes" from François Villon's "The Great Testament" explores the complex interplay between fate, morality, and social circumstance, reflecting on the author's own troubled life. The poem begins with a statement about the harsh lessons that the speaker has learned from "agonizing griefs and woes," admitting that these trials have made him wiser than scholars like Averroes who wrote about Aristotle-the Stagirite. This introductory section serves as a meta-commentary on the nature of life's education: how suffering and marginalization can provide insights that academic or theoretical knowledge cannot offer.

The poem then segues into an autobiographical reflection, detailing how the speaker-presumably Villon himself-found temporary respite in a "fair city" during his impoverished wanderings. Here, he speaks of divine compassion, emphasizing God's desire for sinners to reform rather than face damnation. This is a comforting thought for the speaker, who is aware of his sins but also confident in God's forgiving nature.

Villon then transitions to a story about Diomedes, a pirate brought before Alexander the Great. Charged and condemned for his crimes, Diomedes challenges the morality of the term "robber," questioning why he is labeled so for stealing in a small boat, while Alexander does the same on a grander scale. His argument is rooted in the societal constructs that define morality-constructs often dictated by power dynamics. The tale ends with Alexander, moved by Diomedes' words, pardoning him. Thereafter, Diomedes becomes a "worthy man," highlighting the transformative power of empathy and understanding.

The inclusion of the story of Diomedes serves multiple purposes. It is an allegory that resonates with Villon's own life-a sinner, yes, but one shaped by circumstance and necessity. Just as Diomedes argues that his life of piracy is driven by the force of "destiny," Villon suggests that many of his own actions and choices are constrained by the societal circumstances he finds himself in. The poem claims that if God or fate had provided a merciful figure like Alexander to intersect with his life, he too could have transformed from "sour to sweet."

The poem closes with a poignant reflection on necessity and morality. It argues that "necessity from virtue hinders," and compares the human condition to wolves "seeking prey by hunger prest." This line encapsulates the complexity of morality within the realm of human hardship; it's a survival instinct, according to the poem, that often forces people into morally questionable actions.

Through the life of Diomedes and his own experiences, Villon's poem illuminates the gray areas of morality, challenging the notions of good and evil, right and wrong. It invites us to consider the weight of circumstance and the transformative power of empathy, providing a nuanced portrayal of sin and virtue.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...