Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"A Letter to Her Inconstant Lover" is a poignant and emotionally charged poem written by Isabella Whitney, an English poet from the 16th century. In this poem, Whitney addresses her lover, expressing her feelings of hurt and disappointment caused by his unfaithfulness. She uses examples from classical mythology, such as Theseus, Jason, and Paris, to highlight the consequences of unfaithfulness and the shame that accompanies such actions.

The poem begins with the speaker acknowledging her lover's fickleness and his inability to remain loyal to one woman for an extended period. She wishes him well in his future marriage, hoping that he will find a good wife. Despite her hurt, she admits that she once loved him faithfully and truly. The speaker pleads for honesty and loyalty in their relationship, suggesting that their love could be rekindled if he chooses to be faithful.

Whitney draws parallels between her lover's unfaithfulness and the infamous betrayals of classical figures like Theseus, Jason, and Paris. By referencing these mythical characters, she illustrates the universal nature of infidelity and its destructive consequences. She portrays false lovers as bringing ruin and shame upon themselves and their partners.

The speaker then contemplates her own worth, comparing herself to the virtuous women of history. She hopes that her lover's future wife will possess qualities like Helen's beauty, Penelope's chastity, Lucrece's constancy, and Thisbe's truthfulness. Through these comparisons, she highlights the value of loyalty and virtuousness in a relationship.

As the poem progresses, the speaker expresses resignation to her fate, accepting that her lover may choose to marry someone else. She acknowledges her inability to change the situation and prays for guidance and protection from God for both herself and her lover. Despite her pain, she wishes her lover a fulfilling life, comparing it to the long and prosperous life of King Nestor or the wealth and tranquility of King Xerxes and King Croesus.

The poem concludes with a farewell, as the speaker resolves not to send any more letters to her inconstant lover. She leaves the final words to him to understand her feelings fully.

Isabella Whitney's "A Letter to Her Inconstant Lover" is a powerful exploration of love, loyalty, and the consequences of unfaithfulness. Through vivid imagery and classical references, she communicates her pain and disappointment, and her wish for her lover to find genuine happiness and fulfillment. The poem remains an enduring testament to the universal themes of love and human emotions that continue to resonate with readers today.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...