Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Grammar School Angels" by Rafael Alberti is a poetic exploration of the gap between education and understanding, between formal learning and innate curiosity. The poem speaks about children in a classroom setting, entranced by the mysteries of academic subjects, yet finding them cryptic and unyielding. Rather than a simple critique of formal education, the poem seems to examine the natural wonder and inquiry that education both inspires and fails to satiate.

Alberti uses evocative imagery like the "nocturnal secret of the blackboards" and the "armillary sphere" to express the mystique that these educational tools hold for the children. However, he immediately admits that none among them grasped "why" these instruments were so significant. The children are in a space meant for learning, surrounded by symbols and devices of knowledge, but their understanding remains incomplete, almost surface-level. The blackboard's "nocturnal secret" and the sphere's "exalted" nature stand for the complexities that the young minds can sense but not decipher.

The poem also explores the paradoxes and idiosyncrasies that the children encounter in their lessons: "that a circle may not be round," "that a lunar eclipse misleads the flowers," and "advances the birds' clock." Here, Alberti engages with the theme of the limitations of conventional wisdom and how it often contradicts the natural world and our intuitive understanding of it. This becomes more apparent in lines like, "We only knew that a straight line, if you want, can be curved or broken" and "the wandering stars are children who ignore arithmetic." These lines express how children, not yet fully conditioned by formal educational structures, still see the flexibility and unpredictability in concepts that adults have come to accept as fixed and unchangeable.

Another intriguing aspect is the anthropomorphic treatment of inanimate objects and celestial bodies. In describing fingers "made of Chinese ink" and stars as "children who ignore arithmetic," Alberti adds a layer of magic realism to the poem. These descriptions serve to encapsulate the world of childhood, where imagination reigns supreme, and everything holds the promise of life and mystery.

Alberti's use of irony is palpable when he speaks about the afternoon that "closed bars to open books at dawn." It's as if formal education works against the natural inclinations of life-where bars (symbols of leisure and freedom) are closed, and books (symbols of formal knowledge) are opened. The irony lies in the fact that despite these efforts, "none of us understood anything."

In essence, "Grammar School Angels" serves as an ode to the undying curiosity and unfulfilled quest for understanding that defines childhood. It questions the efficacy of formal education in truly enlightening young minds and instead underscores the persistent, innate wonder that children bring into the classroom-a wonder that is both a complement and a challenge to the structured learning they receive. Alberti presents not a definitive judgment but a reflective observation that nudges the reader to ponder the complexities of learning and understanding.

POEM TEXT:

None of us understood the nocturnal secret of the blackboards

or why the armillary sphere was so exalted when we looked at it.

We only knew that a circle may not be round

and that a lunar eclipse misleads the flowers

and advances the birds' clock.

None of us understood anything:

not even why our fingers were made of Chinese ink

and the afternoon closed bars to open books at dawn.

We only knew that a straight line, if you want, can be curved or broken

and that the wandering stars are children who ignore arithmetic.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...