Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Sherman Alexie's poem "Owl Dancing with Fred Astaire" traverses the cultural terrain between Native American traditions and mainstream American pop culture, exemplified by the iconic figure of Fred Astaire. It seeks to explore the complexities of identity, cultural juxtaposition, and the universal theme of yearning for connection. The poem is a blend of narrative, imagery, and philosophical reflection.

Structured in five stanzas, each section offers a different lens through which to view the act of dancing and its broader implications. It begins by laying the groundwork of the Native American owl dance, emphasizing its importance and social etiquette. This sets the stage for the woman's interaction with Fred Astaire, where the iconic dancer's refusal becomes an emblematic moment that spirals into reflections on culture, longing, and the intricacies of human interaction.

The owl dance itself serves as a powerful metaphor for cultural nuances, simple on the surface but profound in implication. It's a dance anyone can partake in, regardless of age or relationship status. Alexie points out that it's not necessarily romantic, yet underscores the loneliness inherent in many who participate-"all hoping for love/sex/a brief vacation from loneliness." In doing so, the poem reflects on the universality of human desire for connection, transcending cultural boundaries.

The role of Fred Astaire in this context is particularly intriguing. Astaire is quintessentially American, a symbol of grace and skill, but also of a predominantly white culture. The second section compares him to those Native men who've never been asked to owl dance, who "perhaps they secretly wish they were Fred Astaire." This juxtaposition raises questions about cultural assimilation, identity, and the innate human tendency to covet what we do not have.

In the fourth stanza, the imagined presence of Astaire at a powwow serves as an epiphany for him and a moment of reflection for the narrator. The section scrutinizes not just Astaire's wonder at the survival of Native Americans against all odds, but also his own identity as a cultural figure. Astaire is described as the "skinniest white man in the history of the world," yet his allure is unquestionable because he "looks like a dancer."

The final stanza, almost a mathematical equation, delves into the emotional complexities of life. The notion that the number of times one is asked to dance can be quantified and then related to heartbreak encapsulates the yearning and losses that life comprises. The equation concludes with Y being "always equal to Fred Astaire," a statement that encapsulates the elusive grace, joy, and heartbreak that dance-and by extension, life-entails.

"Owl Dancing with Fred Astaire" thus stands as a compelling commentary on cultural intersections and the shared human experience. Whether it's the simple yet meaningful owl dance or the cinematic elegance of Fred Astaire, Alexie underscores that at the core of these varied expressions is a universal yearning for connection, love, and understanding. It invites the reader to ponder the countless dances of life, all imbued with their distinct cultural imprints but ultimately unified in their essence.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...