Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Men Loved Wholly Beyond Wisdom" by Louise Bogan serves as a penetrating inquiry into the nuances of love and wisdom, capturing a sense of both longing and caution. The title itself initiates a contradiction-how can one love "beyond wisdom"? Wisdom, often seen as the accumulation of experience and knowledge, is generally considered a guiding force, particularly in matters as potent as love. Bogan poses the paradox succinctly, illustrating the tension between wise love and unbridled passion.

The poem is infused with compelling imagery. "Men loved wholly beyond wisdom" are said to have "the staff without the banner." Here, the staff, a symbol of authority or leadership, is stripped of its banner-the marker of its identity or cause. The love experienced by these men is powerful but aimless, much like a leader without a clear direction. In contrast, women's love is likened to "a fire in a dry thicket / Rising within women's eyes," an image fraught with urgency and danger. Here, Bogan raises a compelling implication-that the love men "must return" ignites like a wildfire within the female gaze, its presence undeniable but its ramifications uncertain.

A sense of tension pervades the poem. The heart is described as "so subtle now, and trembling," as if the speaker is reckoning with the pull of such irresistible, unwise love. There is an admission of the allure and danger in loving "wholly beyond wisdom," followed by a somewhat rueful wish- "What a marvel to be wise." The poem captures a kind of double consciousness: a longing for a love that defies rationality and a simultaneous yearning for the serenity that comes with wisdom.

The final lines transport us to a scene of quietude in nature-"To be quiet in the fern / Like a thing gone dead and still," offering an alternative to the tumultuous love described earlier. Even this stillness, however, is tinged with disquiet. The "prisoned cricket" in the granite hill plays "terrible dissembling / Music," as if even in moments of apparent peace, there's a lurking tension, a façade that can't quite be shaken.

The poem's historical context can deepen our understanding of its themes. Louise Bogan, one of the most notable female American poets of the 20th century, frequently grappled with themes of emotional intensity, the complications of love, and the constraints society often places on women. Her words in "Men Loved Wholly Beyond Wisdom" resonate within the wider cultural discourse on femininity, desire, and wisdom, issues as relevant today as they were in her time.

The rhyme scheme in this poem is less straightforward than traditional forms, contributing to the work's emotional and thematic complexity. The intricate rhyme scheme serves to tie together the various elements of the poem, creating a sense of unity and depth.

In summation, "Men Loved Wholly Beyond Wisdom" serves as a poignant meditation on the intricacies of love and wisdom, capturing a conflict that is both deeply personal and universally relatable. Through evocative imagery, emotional complexity, and its layered thematic concerns, the poem beckons the reader to contemplate the ever-present tension between passion and prudence.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...