Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Bogan's "To Be Sung on the Water," the reader is presented with a fleeting moment that captures the ephemeral beauty of both human experience and nature. This is a poem steeped in contrasts: movement and stillness, darkness and brightness, guilt and innocence. It masterfully condenses complex emotions and ideas into a brief yet impactful form.

The poem begins with an exclamation, "Beautiful, my delight," as if the speaker is overcome with the beauty of the moment. The word "pass" acts as a command, echoing the transient nature of all things-human emotion, nature's beauty, and even the night sky. The "wave" and "mottled night" serve as metaphors for the passing of time and perhaps a relationship; just as waves recede and the night gives way to dawn, the moment of beauty and delight is fleeting. It "leaves what it cannot save," evoking an air of melancholy and resignation. Bogan employs a rich mixture of "dark and bright" to describe the night, capturing the dualities of human experience.

As the poem moves forward, the reader becomes aware that this is a song of parting, of letting go. The speaker's affection is asked to "pass and be / Less than the guiltless shade." The term "guiltless shade" seems to refer to a spectral or lesser form, perhaps a memory, to which "our vows were said." It suggests a level of innocence, implying that whatever was promised was done so without the weight of future expectations. But now, even that innocent shade is too substantial; the loved one is asked to be "less" than that. It's a painful recognition of the need for separation, presented with a nuanced emotional palette.

The most striking lines come towards the end, where the speaker asks the loved one to be "Less than the sound of the oar / To which our vows were made, - / Less than the sound of its blade / Dipping the stream once more." The oar and its dipping blade serve as powerful metaphors for the efforts made to sustain a relationship. But like the blade lifting from the water, the emotional and physical connection is temporary and destined to be severed. This section heightens the overall mood of transience and loss in the poem.

On a broader cultural note, the poem ties into the themes of love and loss that are universally explored in literature but does so with a sensitivity that is very much characteristic of Bogan's own style and time period. As with much of her work, Bogan finds an exquisite balance between emotional honesty and poetic refinement.

"To Be Sung on the Water" functions as an elegy for a moment, an emotion, or a relationship that cannot be sustained. With concise lyricism, Louise Bogan captures the essence of something incredibly complex: the beauty of ephemeral experiences and the sadness that accompanies their fleeting nature. In doing so, she encapsulates the very human struggle to hold onto what is innately ungraspable, leaving the reader with a sense of the bittersweet impermanence of all things.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...