Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Juana Inesde la Cruz's poem "She Would Choose to Die Rather Than Expose Herself," the dialogue between the character Celia and a rose serves as an extended metaphor for the transience of beauty and the inevitability of mortality. De la Cruz, a 17th-century nun, poet, and scholar, tackles the intersection between fleeting beauty and the more lasting but often cruel markers of time.

The rose, displaying "self-indulgent pomp," serves as a symbol of transient beauty, a beauty that is at once vibrant yet doomed to fade. Its "scarlet lipstick, crimson rouge" are metaphorical enhancements that further accentuate its short-lived glory. Celia, who observes the rose, serves as the voice of wisdom, or perhaps resignation, as she advises the flower to revel in its current state, for even the imminent arrival of "death" cannot rob it of the pleasures of the present.

The phrase "the brief course that your graceful youth obeys" captures the obedience to natural laws, an obedience that governs all living beings, whether human or flower. This deterministic view suggests that beauty, youth, and life itself are bound by the unyielding realities of nature and time. In embracing this, Celia reveals a Stoic acceptance of the life cycle.

The poem's philosophical depth lies in its confronting the irony of existence: it celebrates life's beautiful moments while fully aware of their impermanence. Celia assures the rose that although "death nears so rapidly," it should not "rue your death." Instead, it should consider itself fortunate to "die while beautiful" rather than face "the affront of being old." In a society where physical beauty is highly prized but is also an ever-fading quality, this is a poignant commentary on the societal and perhaps internal pressures to remain youthful and beautiful.

The concept of dying "beautiful" serves as both metaphorical and literal advice. Metaphorically, it suggests that all things beautiful should exit gracefully, at their peak, to be remembered at their best. Literally, it comments on the pressure on women, represented here by Celia, to maintain their beauty lest they suffer the social "affront" of aging. This reflects the often harsh standards of beauty and age, particularly as they apply to women, a theme relevant in de la Cruz's era and still resonant today.

Celia's dialogue with the rose extends far beyond the literal conversation. It becomes a meditation on the ephemeral nature of beauty, the relentless march of time, and the societal expectations that frame our understanding of both. It is a poem that engages with existential themes and holds a mirror to the societal norms that govern our lives. Through the character of Celia and her interaction with the rose, Juana Inesde la Cruz crafts a narrative that is both a lament and a reckoning, a poetic discourse that is as intellectually rigorous as it is emotionally evocative.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...