Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Gluck's "Eurydice," the focus shifts from the more traditional narrative of Orpheus's failed attempt to rescue his beloved from the underworld. Instead, the poem explores Eurydice's experience, feelings, and agency. While the story of Orpheus and Eurydice is a narrative often told to highlight the tragedy of love lost, Gluck reframes it to emphasize Eurydice's emotional and psychological journey, challenging the idea that her fate is merely a function of Orpheus's story.

The poem starts with a statement as abrupt as it is evocative: "Eurydice went back to hell." From the outset, Eurydice is given agency; she 'went' rather than 'was taken.' This reorientation foregrounds the subjectivity of Eurydice's experience in the underworld, her 'hell,' which could be both a literal space and a metaphorical state of mind or circumstance. Gluck delves into the difficulty of "travel," a word that implies not just physical movement but existential transition. Eurydice's transition is described as arduous, yet it becomes "forgotten" upon "arrival," suggesting how the intensity of experiencing change can sometimes be effaced by the conditions that follow.

The poem continues to unfold the challenges Eurydice faces during the "transition" and the "tension" involved in "moving between two worlds." There is a palpable sense of loss, described as a "passage / filled with regret, with longing." Gluck evocatively captures the universal human experience of longing for what has been left behind, whether it's a place, a state of being, or a loved one.

When Eurydice reaches the underworld, the poem conveys that "only for a moment" could "an image of earth's beauty / reach her again." Here, the underworld is described as "gentle, respectful," contrasting sharply with traditional representations that emphasize torment and suffering. It brings into focus Eurydice's conflicted emotions; she mourns for the beauty of the earth, yet finds a certain respectful gentleness in her dark realm. This adds layers of complexity to her character, painting her not as a mere object of rescue but as an individual capable of complex emotions and choices.

The poem concludes with a sharp critique of "human faithlessness," possibly alluding to Orpheus's failure to keep his promise not to look back, leading to her return to the underworld. It raises questions about the ethics and emotional cost of love, fidelity, and human failure. By stating that "to live with human faithlessness / is another matter," the poem challenges the romanticized notions surrounding the story and underscores the difficulty, perhaps even the impossibility, of reconciling human imperfections in the realm of love and commitment.

In its totality, "Eurydice" offers a poignant and thought-provoking interpretation of a well-known myth, shifting the lens to offer a nuanced understanding of Eurydice's experience. It speaks to the complexities of love, loss, and transition, and does so through the eyes of a character traditionally viewed through the prism of her lover's tragedy. It's a deeply empathetic and humanizing retelling that resonates with anyone who has grappled with the complexities of love and the nuances of existence between different 'worlds,' whether emotional, psychological, or even literal.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...