Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Midnight" by Louise Gluck grapples with the complex emotional terrain of domesticity, loss, and the unavoidable passage of time within the context of a relationship. The speaker addresses their "aching heart," revealing internal turmoil under the mundane act of taking out the garbage. In doing so, Gluck explores how seemingly trivial tasks can become stages where life's most significant dramas are acted out.

The speaker starts by chastising their heart, as if it were a disobedient child. They mock its "Ridiculous errand," implying that its emotional expression is not only misplaced but is also derailing them from their supposed responsibilities. One can sense a tone of frustration directed both inwardly and outwardly-towards their emotional vulnerability and perhaps the unspoken tensions in their relationship. The speaker notes that it's not their "job / To take out the garbage," but rather "To empty the dishwasher." On one level, these tasks serve to illustrate the domestic roles we assume or are assigned; on another, they serve as metaphors for emotional labor and responsibility. Just as one takes out the garbage or empties the dishwasher, the emotional messiness of a relationship needs to be sorted, and it seems the speaker's heart is neglecting that duty.

The poem criticizes the heart's "showing off," connecting this behavior back to childhood tendencies. It raises the question: Has emotional growth kept pace with the years, or is the heart still that of a child, seeking attention through its aches and whims? What happened to the heart's "famous / Ironic detachment?" The speaker calls for a return to a more composed state of being, but the query rings hollow, almost as if the speaker doesn't fully believe in the emotional restraint they are advocating.

The atmosphere changes when the poem shifts to discuss the "little moonlight" and "tender / Murmurs from the earth," offering a counterpoint to the earlier emotional tumult. However, these natural symbols of calm and renewal serve only to heighten the isolation felt in that "dark garage" of the speaker's mind. The moonlight illuminates, but only enough to showcase the "broken window," possibly a metaphor for emotional or relational fractures.

In the closing lines, the speaker warns their heart about the possible consequences of remaining emotionally inaccessible. This shift from self-inquiry to cautionary counsel deepens the poem's emotional weight, pointing to the long-term cost of not meeting one's partner halfway in communication and emotional investment. "After fifteen years, / His voice could be getting tired; some night / If you don't answer, someone else will answer."

"Midnight" is a profoundly intimate monologue, a conversation between the mind and the heart, questioning the latter's inability or unwillingness to mature, to be accountable in love, and to be present in shared responsibilities. The poem doesn't provide answers; it merely holds a mirror to complexities that can't be ignored any longer. It suggests that, in the theater of everyday life, even the act of taking out the garbage can raise existential questions about love, duty, and the inexorable passage of time.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...