Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Gluck's poem "Pictures of the People in the War," the narrator grapples with the idea of representation and proximity in the context of war photography. The poem begins with the act of pulling down a shade, a metaphor for the distance between the subject of the photograph-the people in the war-and the audience. Despite this distance, the photograph acts as a medium that "draw[s] life out of the paper," highlighting the paradox of how something so still can evoke something so alive, so animated.

The narrator wishes to "first off share / My vision of the thing," pointing to the role of perspective in shaping what we see. In a war photograph, equipment, tanks, and dwellings might typically take center stage, but here the focus is on the "angle of that head / Submerged in fixer there, the bare / Soul in its set." These lines capture the intimacy that can be achieved in a photograph, an intimacy that is rarely, if ever, achieved "within experience," according to the narrator.

The description of "hands were opening to me like / Language" is profoundly poignant. Hands are often associated with action, work, or communication. Here, they're like language-rich, complex, and open to interpretation. They tell their own stories, separate from the larger narrative of war, which is usually dominated by depictions of machinery and destruction. This notion is reinforced by the contrasting image of "tanks and dwellings meanwhile misty in the rear." In most war narratives, it's the machinery and landscape that are in focus, while the individual lives affected blur into the background. Here, however, the human subjects are brought into sharp focus, their hands extended in a silent language of humanity amid chaos.

The language of photography-angle, fixer, speed, lighting-serves to further blur the lines between art and reality. The narrator is aware of this tension, using the technical aspects of photography as a means to capture "the bare / Soul in its set." But even the photographer can't escape the inherent limitations of their medium-limitations that prevent them from getting "so close to anyone within experience."

The poem speaks to the paradox of proximity and distance, of intimacy and detachment, inherent in any form of representation, particularly in the fraught context of war. Through this lens, "Pictures of the People in the War" becomes a meta-commentary on the role of art and representation in our understanding of human suffering and conflict. Even as the poem grapples with the ethical and philosophical complexities of its subject matter, it does so with a haunting simplicity, leaving us to ponder the profound disconnect between what is seen and what is experienced.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...