Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Saints," Louise Gluck delves into the complexities of familial relationships and spiritual nature through the contrasting experiences of two women in a family, an aunt and a grandmother. The two are regarded as "saints," a term loaded with implications of purity, devotion, and benevolence. However, as the poem unfolds, it becomes evident that their sainthood manifests differently in their lives. The poem deftly employs the metaphor of the sea to explore the inherent differences between the two women's spiritual experiences, and through this metaphor, it questions the notions of fate, suffering, and the nature of life itself.

The speaker's grandmother appears as a figure of tranquility and caution, a person "walking in calm water." Her life is described as "tranquil, even at the end," indicating a harmony between her spiritual nature and the world that surrounds her. She is "like a person for whom the sea couldn't bring itself to hurt." This raises an intriguing question: Is it her caution and conservatism that protect her from suffering, or is she simply fortunate, blessed with a fate that is inherently less turbulent?

Contrastingly, the aunt's spiritual journey is fraught with challenges. When she takes "the same path," the sea attacks her, the waves break over her. The sea is not simply a metaphorical element here; it embodies the complex, often arbitrary ways of fate. The aunt's life is defined by loss and struggle, a testament to how "the Fates respond / to a true spiritual nature."

While the grandmother's life seems less afflicted, it's crucial to note the implication that she "escaped suffering" through her cautiousness. Here, Gluck seems to probe the relationship between spirituality and suffering. Is the avoidance of suffering indicative of a lesser spiritual nature? The contrasting experiences of the two women in the poem open up a multifaceted discussion about the nature of spirituality, ethical integrity, and human suffering.

The poem's concluding lines focus on the aunt's unyielding perception of the sea, or life, as neither evil nor benevolent. "To her, it is what it is: / where it touches land, it must turn to violence." In these lines, there's a tacit acceptance of the inherent duality of life-the beauty and the brutality, the love and the loss. The sea, like life, is neutral in its essence; it's the contact with the corporeal, represented by the "land," that manifests as violence or serenity.

"Saints" challenges us to rethink our understanding of virtue, spirituality, and the inherent randomness of human experience. Gluck doesn't offer clear answers but leaves us in a space of ambiguity, nudging us to ponder the intricacies of fate and the resilience of human spirit in the face of unavoidable suffering. The poem serves as a compelling study of the contrasts and paradoxes that shape our understanding of spirituality, showing how two lives, seemingly on similar paths, can diverge in profoundly different ways.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...