Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Gluck's poem "Scilla," the voice of the poem boldly confronts human assumptions about individuality, purpose, and the divine. The opening line, "Not I, you idiot, not self, but we, we-waves," jarringly introduces us to a collective voice that derides human egoism. This collective voice is not just a collective human voice but could also be seen as the voice of nature, of the universe, or even the divine. This entity observes human behavior, specifically our self-centeredness and our constant quest for meaning, and responds with a dismissive critique.

The line "waves of sky blue like a critique of heaven" suggests a natural order that challenges our idealized concepts of a higher realm. The question "why do you treasure your voice" confronts human arrogance directly. To this collective voice, individual human existence appears insignificant, "to be one thing is to be next to nothing." This phrase underscores the vastness of the universe, or of the collective, compared to individual human life. It's a humbling sentiment, forcing the reader to reconsider the ego's dominance.

The middle section of the poem explores our human yearning for divine validation: "Why do you look up? To hear an echo like the voice of god?" Humans often search for answers or validation from a higher power, thinking of themselves as special, or chosen. The collective voice rebukes this notion, saying "you are all the same to us, solitary, standing above us, planning your silly lives." This line captures a certain futility in human endeavors, especially when considered from a broader, universal perspective.

The latter part of the poem, "you go where you are sent, like all things, where the wind plants you," focuses on the predestined or determined aspects of life that we often overlook. We are subject to the laws of nature, to circumstances, and perhaps to destiny, much like "waves" or any other part of the natural world. The speaker suggests that people are forever "looking down and seeing some image of water, and hearing what? Waves, and over waves, birds singing." Here, the collective voice emphasizes that humans are just a small part of the broader canvas of life. Our interpretations or reflections are just ripples in a larger, more complex tapestry of existence.

"Scilla" serves as a critique of human self-importance and our often myopic view of life. Gluck confronts us with a perspective that we are not accustomed to hearing, one that places human life within the broader context of the natural world, or perhaps even the universe. It's a challenging poem, asking us to step outside our individual selves and consider our place in the grand scheme of things. In doing so, Gluck provokes a reckoning with our own limitations, pushing us to confront uncomfortable truths about human existence in relation to a far more expansive, indifferent cosmos.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...