Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Gluck's poem "Telemachus' Dilemma," the dilemma of how to memorialize parents posthumously becomes a meditation on the complexities of familial relationships, individuality, and the moral responsibilities of remembrance. Told through the voice of Telemachus, son of Odysseus and Penelope in Greek mythology, the poem resonates beyond its mythical context to speak to universal human experiences.

Telemachus struggles with what inscription to write on his parents' tombstone, a seemingly straightforward task that becomes imbued with ethical and emotional weight. His father desires the epitaph "beloved," a word that, according to Telemachus, fittingly encapsulates his father's romantic engagements, "particularly if we count all the women." However, the term marginalizes his mother, who "prefers to be represented by her own achievement." Each parent has a unique vision of how they wish to be memorialized, tied to their individual self-perceptions and egos.

Gluck portrays the parents as individualistic figures with their distinct desires and vanities. In a moment of insightful critique, Telemachus observes that honoring the dead by perpetuating their "vanities" and "projections of themselves" seems incongruous. Here, Gluck taps into the heart of the dilemma: should the inscription aim to comfort the living by enshrining the dead as they saw themselves, or should it seek a more objective, truthful representation?

What complicates the dilemma further is Telemachus' own perspective on his parents. His "taste dictates accuracy without garrulousness," implying that he values a truthful, yet succinct representation over sentimental or ego-driven renditions. However, this "accuracy" is also subjective, shaped by his experiences and observations. He sees his parents "together," but this unity is fluid, sometimes resembling a partnership ("husband and wife") and at other times reflecting opposition ("opposing forces"). This observation beautifully captures the ever-changing, multifaceted nature of familial relationships, where love and conflict often coexist.

The poem delves into the tension between individuality and relational identity in a family context. Telemachus is torn between honoring his parents as separate individuals with their unique vanities and portraying them in a manner that reflects their complex, often contradictory, roles in his life and each other's. This captures a universal truth about family: individuals do not exist in isolation but are continually shaped by, and shaping, their relational roles.

In "Telemachus' Dilemma," Gluck engages with these complex ethical and emotional terrains with deft brevity. The poem serves as an exploration of the difficulties inherent in memorializing individuals who are, in life and death, irrevocably tied to others. It also illuminates the ethical quandaries that come with the responsibility of portraying the deceased, questioning whether this act should serve truth, comfort, or perhaps an uneasy compromise between the two.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...