Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Drowned Children," Louise Gluck takes on a haunting subject matter: the death of children by drowning. The poem becomes a meditation on innocence, the nature of death, and the process of grieving. In its brief lines, the poem tackles a breadth of complexity that is both unsettling and deeply moving.

The opening lines, "You see, they have no judgment. / So it is natural that they should drown," sets the tone for the poem by injecting an eerie logic into the tragic event. By attributing the children's drowning to a lack of judgment, the poem establishes an atmosphere where even the most heart-wrenching losses are part of a natural, albeit bleak, order. This initial assessment challenges our emotional instincts to question and mourn, presenting a world where such losses are not only probable but also inevitable.

The winter setting becomes a character in the poem, a powerful, relentless force that takes the children into its "manifold dark arms." Here, the ice and the pond are both killers and cradlers, enveloping the children in a paradox of destruction and embrace. The imagery of "their wool scarves / floating behind them" is particularly evocative, suggesting remnants of a life, pieces of innocence carried on the water's surface even as the children themselves sink.

Gluck contemplates the nature of their deaths as "different," being so close to life's "beginning." It is as if they have "always been / blind and weightless," making their transition from life to death almost a natural progression rather than an abrupt end. This idea adds an additional layer of sorrow to the poem-the notion that these young lives were so short that death might feel like a continuity rather than an interruption.

The latter part of the poem delves into the realm of dreams and memory, as "the rest is dreamed, the lamp, / the good white cloth that covered the table, / their bodies." Here, Gluck is probably suggesting that for these children, whatever life they had is now akin to a dream, a fleeting memory superseded by their tragic fate. The lamp and the white cloth symbolize home, comfort, and everyday life-things that are now intangible and dream-like to the drowned.

The closing lines incorporate a phantom voice, perhaps that of a grieving parent or community, calling out the children's "names they used / like lures slipping over the pond." These calls serve as a poignant reminder of the void their absence has created-a sense of loss that is "blue and permanent."

"Drowned Children" stands as a profound exploration of the unimaginable pain accompanying the loss of young lives. Gluck does not offer easy answers or sentimental comforts. Instead, she presents a raw, chilling confrontation with death and loss, forcing the reader to grapple with the unsettling realities and questions that such tragedies evoke.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...