Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Gluck's "Triumph of Achilles," the poem navigates the treacherous waters of love, mortality, and the human condition through the lens of the story of Patroclus and Achilles from ancient Greek mythology. This tale, embedded within Homer's "Iliad," serves as a haunting backdrop for an exploration of hierarchical friendships and the inescapable vulnerabilities that come with being mortal.

The poem opens with the assertion that "no one survives," instantly shrouding the narrative in the inevitability of death. Even Achilles, who was "nearly a god," cannot escape this fate. Gluck zeroes in on the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus, subtly critiquing the established legends by pointing out that "the hierarchy is always apparent," yet "the legends cannot be trusted." This skepticism toward established narratives reveals a layer of complexity. Legends, often romanticized, rarely capture the unvarnished dynamics of interpersonal relationships; in this case, the inherent power imbalance between the nearly divine Achilles and the mortal Patroclus.

This power imbalance, however, does not make the grief any less acute. The poem poses the question: "What were the Greek ships on fire compared to this loss?" The scale of personal loss eclipses even the most dramatic of wartime catastrophes, offering a piercing look into the nature of human suffering. Achilles' grief in his tent is described as so profound that "the gods saw he was a man already dead." This line brilliantly brings forth the idea that grief can be a form of living death, emphasizing the mortal part of Achilles, the part capable of love and therefore vulnerable to loss.

The duality of Achilles-part divine, part mortal-is at the core of this poem. His divine aspect grants him extraordinary abilities and near invincibility, but it's his mortal aspect, "the part that loved," which makes him susceptible to the profound grief that follows Patroclus' death. In this light, mortality is both a curse and a gift. It enables deep emotional bonds but also leaves one vulnerable to the inevitable tragedy of loss. The poem serves as a reminder that even for someone as powerful as Achilles, being partially divine is not enough to escape the emotional ravages of mortality.

This "Triumph of Achilles" is not one of victory but rather one of profound vulnerability. It triumphs in revealing the limitations of legends and myths to capture the complexities of human emotions. The real triumph is the willingness to love and to grieve, thereby embracing what it means to be fully human. Gluck's poetic lens not only critiques ancient legends but also enriches our understanding of universal themes, making the story of Achilles and Patroclus resonate across millennia, reminding us of the fragile, beautiful mortality that makes us human.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...