Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Louise Gluck's "World Breaking Apart," the dichotomy between order and chaos is laid bare through the examination of the transient and permanent elements of life, love, and suffering. The poem presents an intimate tableau of scenes that range from sterile snow to intimate human interaction, all explored with an almost clinical detachment that belies the emotional heft of the subject matter.

The opening lines, "I look out over the sterile snow," ground us in a landscape that symbolizes emotional desolation and barrenness. Objects like a wheelbarrow, a mended fence, and a picnic table are static and serve as markers of human attempts at structure and stability. The mounded snow, compared to "the inverted contents of a bowl," introduces the theme of impermanence. It is shaped by the wind, which has an "impulse to build," perhaps suggesting that even nature attempts to make sense of chaos, to create form where there is none.

Juxtaposed against this natural tableau is the world of human emotions and intellect. The speaker mentions the "square white keys, each stamped / with its single character," symbolizing the definitive ways in which we attempt to frame our thoughts and emotions. The speaker reflects on the idea that the "mind's shattering" could result in releasing "the objects of its scrutiny," as if intellectual disarray could somehow lead to a more genuine, unfiltered understanding of the world. Here, too, we see the tension between control and chaos.

The poem goes on to describe an almost idyllic scene: "a man reaching for his wife's hand / across a slatted table, and quietly covering it, / as though his will enclosed it in that gesture." This moment captures human connection and the illusion of permanence, which is then immediately undercut by the lines that follow. Gluck writes that she saw these scenes "come apart," implying that nothing is as stable as it appears, not even love.

There is a dream-like quality to the speaker's observations, "I dreamed of watching that / the way we watched the stars on summer evenings." However, the dream comes crashing down with the unflinching assertion, "There is no such light." The poem concludes with a stark reality: pain "changes almost nothing." Just like the winter wind, pain may leave "settled forms in the snow," but they are ultimately "Known, identifiable," but useless.

"World Breaking Apart" offers a compelling meditation on the complexity and impermanence of both the emotional and physical realms. Even as we attempt to build-be it relationships, thoughts, or even barriers-the forces of nature, time, and human frailty make a mockery of our endeavors. Yet, even in this uncertainty, Gluck hints at the beauty of ephemeral moments. The poem itself becomes an example of how art can capture the transient and give it form, if only for a brief time.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...