Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Bauldy Fraser" by James Hogg is a narrative poem that tells the story of a man named Bauldy Fraser who fought in the Battle of Culloden. The poem portrays the defeat and retreat of the Highland clans during the battle and reflects on the consequences of their defeat.

The poem begins with Bauldy Fraser introducing himself as an old and poor man who suffered injuries during the Battle of Culloden on Culloden Moor. He describes how the Highland clans, known for their bravery and resilience, initially hoped to turn the tide of the battle but were ultimately routed and forced to flee over the hills.

The poet vividly describes the chaos of the battle, with blows, punches, and blind eyes, while highlighting the gleaming Highland swords. However, the cannons of the opposing forces caused great damage, breaking bones and tearing clothing. The Highlanders find themselves caught between the hill and the sea, realizing the perilous situation they are in.

Bauldy Fraser expresses the belief that if Charles Stuart (Charlie) and the brave Lochiel had been present, they could have led the Highlanders to victory. He envisions a scenario where they meet Cumberland (likely referring to William Augustus, Duke of Cumberland), and the German sea would be stained with the blood of the enemy. However, the reality is that the Highlanders suffer heavy losses and many young men lie wounded on the battlefield.

In a moment of desperation, when Charlie and Macpherson consider regrouping to make another attempt, Donald jumps over a burn and declares that she will not turn back, causing others to follow. The Highlanders, exhausted and looking back in fear, flee from the battlefield, their hopes dashed.

The poem reflects on the tragedy and loss of life at the Battle of Culloden. The poet laments the thousands who were killed or hanged, and he questions Cumberland's motives for ravaging the Highland glens. The Highlanders' only crime, he suggests, was their loyalty to their cause and love for their leader.

The poem ends with a note of resilience and a call for trust in the honest Highland lad, symbolized by the blue bonnet and belted plaid. Despite the defeat at Culloden, the poet suggests that the Highland spirit and loyalty will endure, and the Highlanders will stand firm when called upon again.

In terms of poetic devices, the poem employs rhyme and rhythm to create a musical and storytelling quality. The rhyme scheme is varied throughout the poem, with alternating rhymes and occasional slant rhymes. This adds to the lyrical flow and oral tradition of the poem, which would have been recited or sung. The use of vivid imagery helps to paint a picture of the battle and its aftermath, evoking emotions of loss, despair, and resilience.

Overall, "Bauldy Fraser" by James Hogg is a poignant portrayal of the Battle of Culloden and its impact on the Highlanders. It captures the bravery, suffering, and eventual retreat of the Highland clans, while reflecting on the consequences of their defeat and expressing a sense of hope for the future.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...