Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Alexander Laing's poem "Jock, Rab, and Tam" takes a satirical look at the aspirations of parents for their children, especially towards the 'learned professions' - law, medicine, and clergy. Laing uses humor and irony to comment on the mismatch between the abilities of the boys and the professions their parents choose for them.

Provenance and Context

Alexander Laing, a Scottish poet, was known for his wit, humor, and regional dialect in his poetry. His works often revolve around Scottish life, reflecting on social norms and attitudes. "Jock, Rab, and Tam," in its exploration of parental expectations and societal standards, fits well into Laing's oeuvre.

Theme Analysis

The primary theme in "Jock, Rab, and Tam" is the unrealistic and perhaps misguided expectations parents might place on their children. Each stanza introduces a boy - Jock, Rab, and Tam - each with distinct shortcomings. Yet, their parents believe that sending them to school will make them successful in prestigious professions - law, medicine, and the ministry, respectively.

Laing also criticizes societal attitudes toward the learned professions. Despite Jock being "cunnin's the Deil," his father sees him as a future lawyer. Rab, who lacks practical skills, is thought to become a doctor, while the "witless" Tam is predicted to be a minister. The poem, therefore, subtly questions the qualities society values in these professions.

Poetic Devices

The poem maintains a consistent ABAB rhyme scheme throughout, providing a rhythm and structure that complements its narrative style and content.

Laing's use of Scottish dialect creates an authentic voice and setting for the poem. It not only reflects the regional color but also enhances the humor and character portrayal in the poem.

Repetition is a critical device in this poem. The repeated phrase, "We'll gie the callan a while o' the schule," emphasizes the parents' firm belief in education as a transformative tool, regardless of their children's apparent aptitude.

Irony is prevalent throughout the poem. Despite the boys' evident flaws, their parents still harbor high aspirations for them, reflecting the discrepancy between reality and expectation.

Conclusion

"Jock, Rab, and Tam" is a humorous, yet thought-provoking poem that questions societal norms, parental expectations, and the attributes associated with the learned professions. Through the use of irony, repetition, and authentic dialect, Alexander Laing creates a richly satirical portrayal of ambition and aspiration in rural Scottish life.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...