Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"New York City 1970" by Audre Lorde is a searing critique of urban decay, social injustice, and the disillusionment of the American Dream. Written in 1971 and divided into two sections, the poem is a potent commentary on a city and a nation in crisis, depicting New York as a deteriorating landscape that has lost its beauty and its promise. Yet, amidst the bleakness, there is a glimmer of hope, a spark of potential transformation that might just save the future generation.

The first section of the poem interrogates the concept of change in an urban environment that seems to have descended into chaos. Lorde employs striking imagery like "frayed slogan underwear" and "an emptied can of yesterday's meanings" to emphasize how the rhetoric of change has become stale and meaningless. The questioning tone of "How do you spell change" and "What does the we-bird see with / who has lost its I's?" suggests a community that has lost its vision and individuality, now wrestling with a fractured identity.

However, the poem doesn't linger in despair; it pivots toward a form of radical hope: "I have come to believe in death and renewal by fire." Here, fire becomes a symbol of both destruction and rebirth, a cleansing agent that could pave the way for a better future. The speaker is resigned yet hopeful that her children will inherit a city forged anew from the fires of its past agonies, "blackened again but this time with a sense of purpose."

The second section intensifies this dual sense of despair and hope. The city is described as an "empire's altar," a sacrificial ground for all its failings, including racial and social injustices. The speaker navigates through "fluorescent alleys" and watches as "flames walk the streets," accentuating the city's hellish aspects. Yet, it is within this chaos that the speaker finds the possibility of renewal. She submits herself and her children "to the fire, to the rage, to the ritual sacrifications," believing that they will be "tried as new steel is tried." In other words, through hardship and struggle, they will find their strength.

The poem concludes on a note of devastating clarity: "there is nothing worth salvage left in this city / but faint reedy voices like echoes / of once beautiful children." This line encapsulates the tragedy and the promise, highlighting that while the city has been corrupted and is seemingly beyond redemption, the potential for rebirth resides in its youngest inhabitants.

Lorde's "New York City 1970" presents a textured and multidimensional critique of urban life and societal failure. It acknowledges the existential angst and ethical quandaries of living in a city that represents both the pinnacle of American aspiration and the depths of its failures. The poem is rooted in its historical moment, capturing the unrest and disillusionment of the 1970s, yet its themes resonate across time, offering a lens through which we might examine the continual challenges and hopes of urban life. Lorde's work remains a poignant reminder that from the ashes of destruction, there is always the potential for rebirth-if we are willing to confront and learn from our collective agonies.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...