Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"If I Were a Poet" by Antonio Machado serves as an eloquent meditation on the ideal of love, the nature of poetry, and the ineffable quality of human emotion. The poem's inherent beauty lies not just in its explicit words, but also in its subtext, the unspoken sentiments that linger between the lines.

The opening lines establish a hypothetical scenario, "If I were a poet / of love, I would make / a poem for your eyes as clear / as the transparent water in the marble pool." Here, Machado offers a poetic ideal, an aspiration that is not merely about crafting verses but about creating a piece of art so pure and clear it would rival the transparency of water. The poet's self-awareness is palpable-he is conscious of the inherent limitations in language to capture something as elusive as the expression of eyes.

As the poem unfolds, we see Machado's intricate dance between the abstract and the tangible. The eyes are given primacy, portrayed as windows to a soul that is as clear as a marble pool, invoking a sense of purity and tranquility. In his "water poem," he endeavors to capture this essence, stating, "I know your eyes do not answer mine, / they look and do not question when they look." This phrase conveys the inscrutability of the gaze, acknowledging that while eyes may communicate, they don't necessarily have to engage in a dialogue. The eyes he describes possess their own sense of self, an internal world that remains untethered by the observer's gaze or interpretations.

Machado continues, emphasizing the eyes' unspoken wisdom and innate quality: "your eyes have the calm and good light, / the good light of the blossoming world, / that I saw one day / from the arms of my mother." The poet links the eyes to a cosmic sense of good, a 'blossoming world,' and roots this perception in his earliest memories of the world as seen from his mother's arms. In doing so, he elevates the eyes from mere physical features to symbols of inherent goodness and universal truths. They become a link to something primal and essential, embodying the 'good light' that illuminates life itself.

What strikes the reader most, perhaps, is Machado's humility in the face of love and beauty. He doesn't claim to fully understand or articulate the grandeur of what he witnesses; rather, he posits himself as an observer, awed and humbled by the magnificence he can never completely capture. The poem, in its entirety, serves as an ode to both the futility and the necessity of attempting to describe love's intricate phenomena.

Machado acknowledges the limitation of words, yet through this very acknowledgment, he manages to encapsulate the indescribable-a quality that places this poem within the lofty realm of timeless art. "If I Were a Poet" stands as a testament to the enduring power of poetry to explore the vast landscape of human emotion, even when those emotions seem ineffable and beyond reach.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...