Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Wish," a sparse yet poignant poem by William Stanley Merwin, takes us into a moment of personal reckoning, where the speaker confronts limitations and the inevitable forces that bind us. The poem commences with an arresting image: "The star in my / Hand is falling." This line carries a heavy emotional weight, implying that something once held as an aspiration or an ideal is slipping away, beyond the speaker's grasp. Stars often symbolize hope, dreams, or guiding lights, and the act of it falling suggests a loss or a coming to terms with reality.

The second stanza introduces an almost bureaucratic obstacle to the speaker's wish: "All the uniforms know what's no use." Uniforms here likely symbolize authority, conformity, or established systems that hold power. These "uniforms" are aware of the futility of the speaker's star or wish, serving as gatekeepers who restrict or deny access to those lofty ideals. There's a feeling of disillusionment and an acknowledgment of the harsh reality that some dreams will remain unfulfilled, as they are deemed "no use" by the powers that be.

However, the poem doesn't end in defeat but in a resolve: "May I bow to Necessity not / To her hirelings." The speaker wishes to show deference to 'Necessity,' a personification of the inevitable and undeniable facts of life. Yet, there's a crucial distinction; the speaker chooses not to bow to "her hirelings," the agents or emissaries of necessity, who may be symbolized by the "uniforms" mentioned earlier. There's an implied criticism of blind obedience to authority, of letting external systems define what's possible or necessary for one.

In essence, the poem encapsulates a struggle between individual will and external limitations. While it acknowledges that not all wishes can be realized-some stars will fall-it also suggests that it's essential to distinguish between what is genuinely unattainable and what is made so by societal or authoritative constraints. The poem advocates for a nuanced understanding of surrender; one should yield to the fundamental realities of life but should question and resist the arbitrary limitations imposed by societal expectations or authorities.

In its few lines, "Wish" packs in a complex interplay of aspiration, authority, and acceptance. Merwin's economical use of language heightens the emotional impact, making each word, each image, and each pause heavy with significance. He confronts us with the universal struggle against both internal and external limitations, urging us to keep our dignity even when we have to let go of our dreams. By doing so, the poem itself becomes a star in the reader's hand, illuminating the profound complexities of human experience.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...