Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"To A Friend" by Boris Leonidovich Pasternak presents a nuanced look at the individual's relationship to society, particularly within the context of the Soviet Union's Five-Year Plan. Pasternak, a critical figure in 20th-century Russian literature, navigates the turbulent waters of political idealism and personal struggle. The poem can be read as a commentary on the societal ethos of the Soviet era, critiquing the ideological rigidity and lack of space for individual freedom and creativity.

The poem begins with the speaker acknowledging the necessity of hardship for growth: "stumbling against shadows, Darkness could never have arrived at light?" This rhetorical question hints at the dialectical process often cited as the driving force behind history in Marxist theory. However, the speaker does not fully embrace the utilitarian view that the happiness of millions can outweigh the suffering of hundreds. The line "Do I rate happy hundreds over millions" reveals a tension between individual experience and collective good, asking if one should become "a monster" for the greater cause.

The Five-Year Plan, a series of nation-wide economic goals set by the Communist Party, serves as a "yardstick" for the speaker's life. Here, Pasternak engages with the notion that individual fate is closely tied to the collective project. But even as the speaker identifies with the communal endeavor ("Its rise and fall my own"), he questions the relevance of such grand schemes to individual human experience: "What shall I do with my thorax / And with what's slower than inertia is?"

The poem touches upon the issue of artistic freedom under a regime that prioritizes economic and political objectives. Pasternak writes, "The great Soviet gives to the highest passions / In these brave days each one its rightful place," acknowledging that the Soviet system did strive to organize society around collective goals and ideals. However, he points out the system's failure to provide a "vacant" space for the poet. The absence of such a space is an ominous sign, as the poem ends with the warning, "When that's not empty, look for danger's face."

Pasternak's "To A Friend" serves as a vital critique of a society so focused on collective aims that it overlooks individual needs and freedoms, particularly the freedom to create and interpret art. The poem stands as a complex negotiation between collective ideals and individual creative spirit, taking note of the looming dangers when such spirit is stifled. This tension between the individual and the collective is not only a snapshot of the Soviet experience but also raises timeless questions about the place of art and individual expression within any political system.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...