Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Ezra Pound's "Piccadilly" probes the dichotomy between beauty and depravity, between the sublime and the ignoble, against the backdrop of what seems to be an urban setting. Though the poem is short, it carries a profound undertone of lament for human potential lost or wasted, inviting the reader to consider the range of human experience and emotion.

The poem opens with "Beautiful, tragical faces," immediately setting a tone of dichotomy. The word "beautiful" brings to mind aesthetic, perhaps even divine, harmony, while "tragical" introduces the concept of downfall or suffering. These faces were once "whole," but are now "so sunken." Here, Pound crystallizes the tragedy of lost potential, using "whole" as a metaphor for a kind of original, unspoiled beauty or goodness that has been compromised.

Contrastingly, the second stanza presents the "vile" faces, those that are "sodden and drunken." Here again, Pound inspects a different facet of human downfall-not from grace or beauty, but from dignity and self-control. What's striking is that these faces "might have been loved," suggesting that their current state is not a reflection of their inherent worth, but rather of choices made or circumstances endured.

The recurring question, "Who hath forgotten you?" serves as an indictment not just of the individuals depicted, but also of society at large. It suggests societal neglect or collective amnesia, wherein people are reduced to their current states, stripped of their history and potential. The term "forgotten" is particularly poignant; it implies that there was, at one point, a recognition or acknowledgment of their humanity, which has since been lost.

The poem closes with a paradox. The speaker can't "pity" the "gross, the coarse, the brazen" as perhaps he should, but he's irresistibly drawn to the "delicate, wistful faces." This emotional complexity enriches the poem's thematic depth. It recognizes that our emotional or moral obligations may not align neatly with our actual feelings. In that dissonance lies a complex portrait of human empathy and judgment.

In conclusion, "Piccadilly" stands as a compelling commentary on the complexity of human nature and societal judgment. It questions how we perceive and remember the downtrodden, challenging us to broaden our emotional and moral horizons. Despite its brevity, the poem speaks volumes about neglect, empathy, and the human capacity for both beauty and downfall.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...