Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In the seventeenth poem of Adrienne Cecile Rich's series "Twenty-One Love Poems," the poem grapples with the complexities of love, challenging predestined romantic narratives and exploring the impact of internal and external forces on relationships. The speaker begins with a bold assertion: "No one's fated or doomed to love anyone." With this statement, the poem immediately rejects the romantic notion of destiny, pulling us into a more realistic arena where love is not the result of fate but rather a series of "accidents."

The speaker continues to deconstruct traditional narratives of love by saying, "we're not heroines," and dismisses the legendary story of "Tristan und Isolde" as "scarcely the story." In doing so, Rich underscores the fact that real-life love is much more complex and far less heroic than the tales we've been told. She asserts that women, in particular, should be cautious of confusing "love and death," cautioning against the fatalistic, all-consuming passions often found in romantic literature.

The poem subtly criticizes the idea that love should be preserved or captured through external means-like a "tape-recorder." The tape-recorder serves as a metaphor for the societal frameworks and cultural narratives that attempt to define love. These external definitions often fall short of capturing the true essence of personal experience. The speaker wishes that the tape-recorder "should have listened to us," indicating a desire for a more authentic account of love's trials and tribulations, instead of a canned, one-size-fits-all narrative.

Rich introduces the idea of instructing "those after us," which adds a layer of urgency to the poem. The speaker suggests that the real lessons to be gleaned are not from romantic ideals but from understanding "the forces they had ranged against us" and "the forces we had ranged within us." These forces-be they societal expectations, personal insecurities, or other invisible pressures-wield enormous influence over the course of a relationship. Love, the poem argues, is an ongoing struggle against these external and internal factors.

While the poem serves as a cautionary tale about the pitfalls of romantic idealization, it also becomes a declaration of authenticity. It advocates for understanding love in its most real terms-as something fought for and maintained against significant odds. Rich ends the poem by pointing out that these forces exist "against us and within us," implying that understanding love's complexities requires an awareness of both external societal pressures and internal emotional landscapes.

In its nuanced exploration of love's complexities, the poem serves as both a critique of romantic narratives and a call for more realistic, self-aware approaches to understanding relationships. It's a powerful reminder that love is not a predestined path but a labyrinth of choices, challenges, and opportunities for growth.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...