Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Analyzing "Where Does This Tenderness Come From?" by Marina Ivanovna Tsvetaeva

The Mystery of Emotion

Marina Tsvetaeva's "Where Does This Tenderness Come From?" navigates the complex emotions of love and attraction. A central motif of the poem is the question it repeatedly asks: "Where does such tenderness come from?" This query serves as an emotional pillar, emphasizing the inexplicable nature of love and intimacy. The speaker is gripped by a sentiment so overwhelming that it demands an origin story, yet remains enigmatic.

Themes: Unprecedented Love and Emotional Complexity

The speaker begins by acknowledging past experiences, winding other curls around her finger and kissing lips darker than the current lover's. Despite this, the tenderness she feels now is presented as unparalleled: "But I've never heard words like this / in the night." The poem seems to argue that every love, while perhaps reminiscent of past loves, has its unique lexicon, its singular emotional syntax that sets it apart.

Style and Structure

The poem adopts a free verse structure with no specific rhyme scheme, allowing Tsvetaeva the liberty to explore her emotions unhindered. The poem is punctuated by parentheses encapsulating the recurring question, "Where does such tenderness come from?" This gives the sense that the query is almost an aside, a whisper to oneself in a moment of awe and disbelief. These parentheses serve as emotional parentheses in the text, a space where the speaker takes a step back to ponder the profound impact of the moment.

Contextual Background

Written in 1916, this poem comes from a period of great social and emotional upheaval, during World War I and preceding the Russian Revolution. Tsvetaeva herself had complex relationships throughout her life, including with fellow poets. The date of the poem might suggest a layer of urgency and poignancy; a young poet wandering through town with long eyelashes could easily be a soldier or someone whose time in the speaker's life is limited.

The Ending: An Emotional Enigma

The poem concludes with a striking image: "you and your eyelashes-longer than anyone's." This simple yet profound observation crystallizes the idea that love's unique tenderness often rests in the smallest details. At the same time, the speaker is left in a state of emotional perplexity. "And what will I do with it?" she asks. This line encapsulates the poem's essence-a beautiful yet complex emotional experience with no simple origins or easy answers.

Conclusion

"Where Does This Tenderness Come From?" is a delicate, intimate exploration of love's complex emotional landscape. Through poignant language and a fluid structure, Tsvetaeva masterfully captures the unfathomable nature of human emotions. The poem leaves the reader with a lingering question that mirrors its own recurrent query: Where does such profound poetry come from? Like the tenderness it describes, the poem itself stands as a beautiful enigma, forever provoking thought and feeling in its readers.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...