Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In the sixteenth installment of Adrienne Cecile Rich's "Twenty-One Love Poems," the concept of distance-both physical and emotional-is examined through the intimacy of shared and remembered experiences. The speaker begins by placing herself "Across a city" from her lover, immediately setting up a spatial separation. Yet, the spatial divide is instantly countered with a spiritual closeness: "I'm with you," the speaker says, as if to undermine the importance of physical proximity in the face of emotional intimacy.

The speaker then takes the reader on a journey through a series of shared memories, as if drawing from a repository of past moments to nourish the present. There is a night in August, "moony, inlet-warm, seabathed," and a cabin with a "salt-mist orchard" and the "music of the sea." These descriptions are so vivid, so sensory-rich, that they seem to break down the barriers of space and time. This flashback serves to make the current separation not just bearable but, in a way, meaningless.

Moreover, the placement of personal items-"our brushes, books, vials"-on the "dressing-table" introduces a sense of domesticity and partnership. This glimpse into their private life is poignant and adds a layer of depth to the relationship, hinting that their connection is not just built on romantic highs but also on mundane daily experiences.

While the poem extols the power of shared memories, it also explores the dimensions of personal closeness despite physical distance. "This island of Manhattan is wide enough / for both of us, and narrow," says the speaker, suggesting that even within the vastness of a city, two souls can find a closeness, a private space that is uniquely theirs. The speaker feels confident that she knows how her lover's "face / lies upturned," how "grief and laughter sleep together" in her "generous, delicate mouth." The attention to such specific, intimate details serves to measure the depth of their emotional closeness, reinforcing that love is not just about being physically near but also about deeply knowing and accepting another.

Rich masterfully uses the backdrop of the city and natural elements to mirror the complexities and contradictions of love and distance. In doing so, she compels the reader to question conventional notions of intimacy and closeness, underscoring that the power of shared experiences and emotional understanding can transcend physical separations. The poem seems to argue that love, in its truest form, exists in the depth of our being, in our ability to be emotionally present even when we are physically apart.