Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Carolyn Kizer's poem "Medicine" juxtaposes the evolution of medical practice over generations, contrasting the humble, community-based approach of her grandfather's time with more contemporary, personal moments of medical care. Through vivid imagery and poignant reflections, Kizer captures the essence of human connection within the medical field.

The poem opens with a clear statement about change: "The practice of medicine / Is not what it was / In my grandfather's time." This sets the stage for a nostalgic comparison between the past and present, highlighting how medical practice has evolved.

Kizer vividly recalls her grandfather's experiences: "Of weeks that went by / When he would be paid / Only in chickens / Or only in potatoes." This imagery paints a picture of a time when medical care was often compensated with whatever the patients could afford, emphasizing a more direct and personal exchange between doctor and patient. The mention of "striking miners / In Montrose or Telluride / Who could not pay at all" underscores the community's reliance on the doctor's goodwill and commitment, reflecting a deep sense of duty and altruism.

The poem continues with touching anecdotes: "Of delivering babies / (A total of twenty) / For a tribe of dirt farmers / Who paid one new-laid egg / Or a cup of springwater." These lines highlight the simplicity and purity of the exchanges, where the value of life and health transcends monetary payment. The description of "sweating a breech birth / And twins at that, / At five in the morning" captures the physical and emotional challenges faced by the doctor, while "mighty good water" conveys the profound gratitude and relief felt in such moments.

The poem then shifts to a heartwarming scene: "When, fifty years later, / He came back to the mountains / Middle-aged babies / Ran up in the street / Crying, Doc! Doc! eyes streaming, / Tried to kiss his old hands." This reunion reflects the lasting impact of the grandfather's care and dedication, symbolizing the deep bonds formed through years of selfless service.

Kizer acknowledges the changes in modern medical practice but notes its enduring humanity: "No, the practice of medicine / Is not what it was, / But it has its moments." This transition prepares the reader for a personal anecdote that bridges past and present.

The poem's final stanza recounts a deeply personal and intimate moment: "That morning in surgery / I regained consciousness / A little too early / And found the doctor / Kissing my hand, / Whispering, whispering / It's all right darling, / You're going to live." This contemporary experience of medical care echoes the compassion and tenderness of her grandfather's time, highlighting the continuity of human connection and care within the profession.

"Medicine" by Carolyn Kizer is a reflective and heartfelt poem that captures the evolution of medical practice while celebrating the enduring spirit of compassion and human connection. Through her vivid recollections and personal anecdotes, Kizer illustrates how the essence of care and dedication remains constant, even as the methods and circumstances change. The poem invites readers to appreciate the profound impact of medical practitioners and the moments of kindness and connection that define the true practice of medicine.