Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

John Updike's poem "An Ode" responds wittily and critically to a call from "Life" magazine for an "American novel" that mirrors the burgeoning power and prosperity of the United States during a particularly vibrant historical period. The poem is structured as a classical ode with alternating strophes and antistrophes, where each section confronts and then sardonically subverts the magazine's somewhat simplistic and prescriptive view of what American literature should embody.

Strophe 1 begins with a quotation from "Life" that disparages contemporary American literature as sounding as if it were written by "an unemployed homosexual," a statement reflecting the era's conservative and homophobic attitudes. This opening sets a tone of critique against narrow perceptions of cultural and artistic value.

Antistrophe 1 playfully counters this criticism by sarcastically proposing to write a novel that conforms exactly to a heteronormative, idyllic American narrative, exaggeratedly praising the day and expressing love for his wife. This passage mocks the magazine's call for a sanitized, overly simplistic portrayal of American life.

Strophe 2 continues with another quote from the magazine, emphasizing the potential of modern achievements to provide material for a new American saga. The magazine's language suggests a yearning for grand narratives that affirm national identity and greatness, reflecting mid-20th-century American triumphalism.

Antistrophe 2 responds by embracing the idea of a saga, but with a focus on historically significant, yet tangible elements like soil, pitch, and pivotal historical events such as Harpers Ferry and Bunker Hill. This response indicates a desire to root the American narrative in its complex and gritty realities rather than in uncritical celebration.

Strophe 3 cites the magazine's rejection of "Pollyanna literature," which criticizes overly optimistic and naive storytelling. This reflects a demand for a literature that confronts harsher realities.

Antistrophe 3 agrees to eschew naivete but promises to confront reality with a stark portrayal of human experiences, including suffering and death, yet ironically promises a picturesque "sunset at The End," subtly critiquing the still-present desire for stories that conclude with aesthetically pleasing resolutions.

Strophe 4 quotes the magazine's assertion that in every man lies a deep-seated, almost primal affirmation of life's joy and goodness, suggesting a foundational optimism inherent in human nature or perhaps in the American spirit.

Antistrophe 4 embraces this notion of an intrinsic wisdom and joy in life, advocating for literature that says "Yea," celebrating life's goodness, thus completing the ode on a seemingly affirmative note, but with a nuanced acknowledgment of the complexities underlying such affirmations.

Updike's "An Ode" thus serves as both a critique and an engagement with mid-20th-century American literary and cultural expectations. He challenges the prescriptive norms suggested by "Life" magazine, all the while playfully engaging with the forms and themes proposed. The poem itself becomes a meta-commentary not just on the content but on the form and function of American literature in a rapidly changing world. Through this dialogue, Updike underscores the tension between artistic freedom and cultural expectation, emphasizing the depth and diversity of American life and literature.