Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"She Went to Stay" by Robert Creeley is a brief but evocative poem that delves into themes of familial conflict, particularly the complex dynamics between parent and child, and the inherent challenges in attempting to sever or confront those deep-rooted relationships. Through a striking and unusual metaphor, Creeley captures the difficulty and ultimately the inability to fully extricate oneself from the influence of a parent figure, in this case, the mother.

The opening line, "Trying to chop mother down is like hunting deer inside Russia with phalangists for hat-pins," immediately grabs the reader's attention with its vivid and bizarre imagery. The act of "trying to chop mother down" suggests an attempt to confront, reduce, or possibly understand the towering influence or presence of the mother in the speaker's life. This endeavor is likened to "hunting deer inside Russia," which evokes a sense of an expansive, perhaps overwhelming, endeavor given the vastness and complexity of Russia as a setting. The addition of "phalangists for hat-pins" introduces an element of the surreal and further complicates the metaphor with historical and political overtones, as "phalangists" could refer to members of fascist or nationalist movements, adding layers of aggression, conflict, and perhaps ideological struggle to the image.

The simplicity and finality of the statement "I couldn't" starkly contrasts with the elaborate metaphor that precedes it. This admission of failure or resignation underscores the poem's central theme—the inherent difficulty, or impossibility, of fully disentangling oneself from familial ties, especially those as foundational as the relationship with one's mother. Despite the speaker's efforts or desires to "chop down" or overcome the influence, legacy, or challenges associated with their mother, they ultimately acknowledge the futility of such attempts.

"She Went to Stay" is characteristic of Creeley's ability to convey complex emotional and psychological landscapes through concise yet potent language and imagery. The poem invites readers to reflect on their own familial relationships and the often-complicated feelings of connection, obligation, and independence that accompany them. Through its unique metaphor and the candid revelation of the speaker's inability to achieve their goal, the poem speaks to the universal experience of navigating the bonds that shape and sometimes confine us.

Copyright (c) 2024 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...