Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Disquieting Muses," a poem by Sylvia Plath, is an unsettling exploration of the relationship between the poet and her muses, who are neither divine inspirations nor the comforting fables her mother narrated. Instead, these muses are haunting, faceless figures that plague the speaker's life from infancy, making it a somber meditation on creativity, familial relationships, and the complex interplay between nurturing and nature.

The poem opens with a question aimed at the mother, accusing her of introducing the "ill-bred aunt" or "disfigured and unsightly cousin" into the speaker's life. This sets up the framework for the relationship between the speaker, her mother, and her muses, suggesting that the speaker feels her muses are inherited or bestowed upon her without her consent. These muses are described as unsettling figures "with heads like darning-eggs" who nod incessantly, conjuring an eerie and surreal atmosphere.

The mother, presented as a traditional nurturer, is characterized as one who spins stories where witches are "baked into gingerbread," implying a world that is ultimately fair and just. This comforting narrative clashes with the mother's inability to banish the haunting muses who have "stitched bald heads," "Mouthless, eyeless." The world the speaker inhabits, as shaped by her muses, is neither fair nor comforting, contrasting sharply with the stories of her mother. This theme is continued when, during a hurricane, the mother attempts to comfort, but the haunting muses "broke the panes," disturbing the sanctuary her mother tries to provide.

As the poem moves from childhood to adolescence, the tension between the speaker's reality and her mother's nurturing intensifies. Her failure to participate in the school dance due to the shadow of her "dismal-headed Godmothers" disappoints her mother. But the speaker's discordant experience isn't merely a youthful phase; even her attempt at mastering the piano ends in failure. Her touch is "Oddly wooden," her ear "Tone-deaf," implying that the qualities her muses impart are at odds with the traditional modes of expression her mother values.

The ultimate revelation comes when the speaker acknowledges that her learning comes "from muses unhired by you, dear mother." She recognizes a parallel form of inheritance, one that is more mysterious, possibly darker, yet an integral part of her identity. The mother's idealized image, "floating above me in bluest air" on a "green balloon," drifts away, underlining the unbridgeable gap between them. The daughter acknowledges her "traveling companions," the disquieting muses, with whom she shares a lifelong journey, committing to the unutterable "kingdom" they represent.

Thus, "The Disquieting Muses" is not merely an unsettling narrative but a profound commentary on the diverse influences that shape us, often in ways that are beyond the understanding or control of those who wish to nurture us. The poem intricately interweaves the themes of familial bonds, the complexities of the creative mind, and the haunting persistence of influences both benign and malign. And in doing so, it deepens our understanding of the inescapable dichotomies that constitute human experience.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...